Ilderton brings unhappy record to Tuesday night trip - Referee
Monday, 11th Jan 2016 20:20 by Clive Whittingham
QPR have a sorry recent record under referee Eddie Ilderton, with a 4-1 loss at Scunthorpe and 5-0 defeat at Forest included. Not the most encouraging appointment for Tuesday night at Blackburn then.
Referee >>> Eddie Ilderton (Tyne and Wear), veteran referee on the list since 2002. QPR have lost their last three games with this referee, all on the road, conceding ten in the process.
Assistants >>> Graeme Fyvie (Tyne and Wear) and Christopher Akers (South Yorkshire)
Fourth Official >>> Darren Bond (Lancashire)
The West Ham man looks a class act, head and shoulders above his new team mates, and his arrival forced Redknapp to select a formation far more suited to the players at his disposal than the straight-line 4-4-2 rubbish he’s been picking for the past few weeks. There was a lot to like about a back three that saw Nedum Onuoha recalled, and the wing back system suits Armand Traore much better although he was fairly wild here on a difficult playing surface. Onuoha showed the value of actually running forwards, with the ball, and genuine purpose, in the first half when he carried the ball to the heart of the Charlton box but then sadly hit the ground theatrically under minimal contact – referee Eddie Ilderton right to wave that one away. Far too often QPR went sideways or backwards for want of a better option, and when Carroll did try to move the ball positively, too often he gave it away.
Charlton: Y Thuram-Ulien 5; R Wiggins 6, D Dervite 6, M Morrison 6, L Wilson 6; D Poyet 6, D Green 6 (A Ajdarevic, 64, 6), J Jackson 6, J Cousins 6; R Ghoochanneijhad 5 (M Tudgay, 64, 6), S Church 6 (C Harriott, 89, -)
Subs not used: R Wood, M Sordell, B Hamer, M Fox
Goals: Jackson 90+3
QPR: R Green 6; C Hill 6, R Dunne 6, N Onuoha 5; A Hughes 5, J Jenas 3, T Carroll 5 (Y Benayoun, 81, -), A Traore 5, J Hoilett 5 (W Keane 59, 6); K Doyle 5 (M Maiga, 70, 5) R Morrison 6
Subs not used: K Henry, B Murphy, Yun Suk-Young, G O'Neil
Referee – Eddie Ilderton (Tyne and Wear) 7 A decent performance. Correct not to award Nedum Onuoha anything in the first half when he appeared to be fouled on the edge of the area, and allowed the game to flow, making allowances for a difficult pitch, far more than he ever has done on previous QPR appointments.
Knill probably should have been celebrating the opening goal of his reign inside two minutes. Joe Garner gave a hint of what was to come as he beat first Hall and then Shittu to the ball in the penalty area – both the QPR defenders appeared to foul him as he bundled his way through and the league leaders were fortunate referee Eddie Ilderton didn’t blow for a penalty on either occasion.
Referee Eddie Ilderton has always been a bit of a fuss pot whenever we’ve had him in charge of our games, and it was one of numerous very, very soft free kicks he awarded on the day that led to the goal. Hogan Ephraim, well known hard man, was adjudged to have fouled his man tight to the touchline when there was barely any contact made and the ball appeared to have been won cleanly.
After he’d gone off Ishmael Miller, his replacement, did no better and became visibly frustrated by David Mirfin, picking up a stupid yellow card for a violent body check on the former Huddersfield centre half, while Patrick Agyemang did absolutely nothing of any use whatsoever. But no, it’s all Hulse’s fault, despite the fact he actually scored our goal.
Miller’s booking started a spate of yellow cards with O’Connor also carded for fouling Fitz Hall, shortly being withdrawn to a deserved standing ovation and replaced by Josh Wright, and Orr booked for fouling Duffy.
Scunthorpe: Murphy 7, Hughes 6, Mirfin 8, Nelson 7, Gordon 6, O'Connor 9 (Josh Wright 84, -), Togwell 7 (Raynes 90, -), Nunez 7, Duffy 7, Garner 8 (Miller 90, -), Dagnall 7
Subs Not Used: Lillis, Collins, Nolan, Godden
Booked: O'Connor (foul)
Goals: Garner 28 (assisted O’Connor), 48 (assisted Mirfin), O'Connor 58 (unassisted), Duffy 79 (assisted Dagnall)
QPR: Kenny 4, Orr 6, Shittu 5 (Chimbonda 46, 5), Hall 5, Hill 5, Faurlin 6, Derry 5 (Agyemang 62, 5), Routledge 6, Ephraim 5, Smith 5, Hulse 5 (Miller 61, 5)
Subs Not Used: Cerny, Buzsaky, Gorkss, Moen
Booked: Miller (foul), Orr (foul)
Goals: Hulse 7 (assisted Routledge)
Referee: Eddie Ilderton (Tyne & Wear) 5 Never has been my favourite referee and is unlikely to improve in my mind while he referees like this. He’s a referee you can tell never played the game to any kind of level. He’s got no feel of when an advantage should be played and not, when a player is genuinely fouled or is actually looking for a free kick, when a tackle is a good one or a foul. He’s just a fussy, nit picky, irritating official. Of the major decisions, Scunthorpe should have had a penalty after two minutes which he didn’t give.
As the clock moved into double figures we had to endure a minute or so of farcical officiating from our referee Mr Ilderton. Firstly Taarabt lost out in a one on one situation and as the Forest player carried the ball away he appeared to trip over his own feet, as Taarabt was laid out five yards away from him, but a free kick was awarded. QPR were then awarded a bizarre free kick of their own for a nonexistent foul on Buzsaky and with frustrations running high the Hungarian was booked within 30 seconds for a scything scissor challenge from behind on Anderson that left the Forest man on the ground and staff from both benches aggressively heading for the touchline. All caused by rank refereeing.
In fact Mr Ilderton was a picky pain in the backside for most of the evening and entered the fray again after a quarter of an hour when a staggeringly beautiful Forest passing move, that included two back flicks on its way to the edge of the penalty area, was cut short with them still in possession and about to get McKenna in down the right for a meagre shirt tugging offence by Hill on Blackstock as he received the ball with his back to goal on the edge of the penalty box. McKenna was furious advantage had not been played but it was to Forest’s benefit ultimately as Robert Earnshaw stepped up from 20 yards out and curled a free kick a fraction over the wall, which didn’t jump, and into the bottom corner of the net away from Ikeme.
The immediate reaction to the goal from QPR said a lot. Billy Davies has always insisted that every single outfield player go and celebrate goals right down by the corner flag thereby delaying the restart. QPR lined up for the kick off without a word said between them apart from Taarabt who waved his arms around at the referee for allowing the time wasting. No arguments, no inquest, just line up and go again.
Adel Taarabt then became the second QPR player to be booked as he was flagged offside, but smashed the ball high into the stand anyway after the whistle. This began an evening of petulant hand gestures and diving around from Taarabt, although at least when given the ball he could be seen to be making the effort - albeit with no success whatsoever other than a tame bouncing shot straight at Camp that proved to be our only serious effort on goal in the half.
On the half hour it was three nil. Earnshaw hit the deck as Gorkss left a lazy leg hanging out in the penalty area and Ilderton pointed straight to the spot. The Welshman, despite being on a hat trick, handed penalty taking duties onto Dexter Blackstock after a poor miss against Birmingham in the cup over Christmas and Blackstock duly stepped up and whacked the ball into the side netting from 12 yards. An unstoppable penalty even if Ikeme had guessed the right way, which he didn’t – the first spot kick Forest have scored this season.
QPR may have had a penalty of their own five minutes later as Alejandro Faurlin seized on a loose ball on the edge of the area and poked it in behind the last man but rather than hit the deck under contact from Morgan he rode the challenge but could only chase the ball out for a goal kick. Just when you thought the farce could not deepen any further it turns out QPR have signed the only South American in world football who stays on his feet in the penalty box. You really could not make it up.
Nottm Forest: Camp 7, Gunter 7, Morgan 7 (Chambers 72, -), Wilson 7, Cohen 8, Perch 8, McKenna 8, Majewski 9, Anderson 8 (Tyson 69, 7),Blackstock 7 (Adebola 80, -), Earnshaw 8
Subs Not Used: Smith, McGugan, McGoldrick, Moussi
Booked: McKenna (foul)
Goals: Earnshaw 18 (free kick), 21 (assisted Anderson), Blackstock 32 (penalty), Cohen 49 (assisted Perch), Perch 78 (assisted Earnshaw)
QPR: Ikeme 2, Connolly 2, Gorkss 2, Stewart 2 (Ramage 46, 2), Hill 3, Buzsaky 2, Leigertwood 2, Quashie 2, Faurlin 4 (Ephraim 46, 4), Buzsaky 2,Taarabt 3, Simpson 3 (Vine 69, 3)
Subs Not Used: Cerny, Hall, Cook, German
Booked: Buzsaky (foul), Taarabt (kicking ball away), Quashie (off the ball incident)
Referee: Eddie Ilderton (Tyne & Wear) 5 Needlessly picky at times. Four cards and a lot of free kicks considering one of the teams wasn’t making any tackles. One of those referees that immediately blows for a foul after a bone crunching, ball winning tackle when really everybody loves to see that and it only gets both sets of players annoyed. A by the book man, and thoroughly irritating with it. Hard to argue with either the penalty or the free kick for the first goal having seen them again although Earnshaw did go down easily for the former and advantage could easily have been played for the latter.
From the resulting corner Howard whipped the ball in right under the cross bar and Camp did well to claw it away from the goal under huge pressure from Ferenczi in the swirling wind. The Hungarian striker is very good at his job when it comes to bullying the goalkeeper from corners. With referee Eddie Ilderton choosing to stand 30 yards away from the goal and peer through the gloom to try and catch a glimpse of things going on as corners were delivered he was pretty much allowed free reign to do what he liked to Camp as the ball was whipped in. It’s to our keeper’s credit that they didn’t score from one of these situations because it’s when they looked most threatening.
It would be fair to say that Dexter Blackstock was not having his best game, a continuation of recent poor form, but I had to laugh at the QPR fans chanting for Rowan Vine’s introduction. Would this be the same Rowan Vine everybody was moaning about not three days ago at Loftus Road? Nothing quite as fickle as football fans sometimes. The other striker we used on the night, Patrick Agyemang, was anonymous in the first half but worked a lot harder in the second and came back into the game. He didn’t get much of a sight of goal on the night but was wrestled back by the throat in the penalty area midway through the half – Ilderton too far away and poorly positioned so didn’t see it. As we’d come to expect of our match official by this stage.
The game looked to be up as we neared stoppage time when Jon Macken got in behind Fitz Hall and raced through on goal – as much as a man with the acceleration of a bulldozer can race anywhere - but Hall got back at him and bundled the ball out of play with a last ditch tackle. The homes fans screamed for a penalty, Ilderton waved the appeals away and awarded a corner. If he did get anything on the ball then Hall deserves a pat on the back for saving a point, if he didn’t then we can chalk one up in the ‘goes around’ column. Seconds later Leon was chopped down in the box for a certain spot kick – thankfully for QPR the flag had already been raised as Leon was offside.
Barnsley: Steele 7, Foster 6, Nyatanga 7, Souza 7, Van Homoet 7, Campbell-Ryce 8, Hassell, 7, Howard 7, Devaney 6 (Leon 68, 7), Macken 6, Ferenczi 4 (Odejayi 60, 6)
Subs Not Used: Togwell, Ricketts, Potter
QPR: Camp 7, Delaney 6, Hall 7, Mancienne 7, Connolly 7, Buzsaky 5 (Stewart 90, -), Rowlands 8, Leigertwood 4, Balanta 7 (Ephraim 62, 6), Blackstock 5 (Vine 78, 5), Agyemang 6
Subs Not Used: Pickens, Lee
Booked: Hall (foul), Delaney (foul)
Referee: Eddie Ilderton (Tyne & Wear) 4 - Positioning was consistently awful and was therefore always a long, long, long way away from any incident that took place. Compare him to Steve Bennett, not a particularly good elite official himself, at the weekend when he was right on the spot of any foul with a quick blast of the whistle and away we went again and the difference was stark. I lost count of the amount of times neither he nor his linesman, one of which showed no signs of life whatsoever throughout the game, looked blankly at each other and then guessed a decision. Missed Patrick Agyemang being pulled back by the neck after turning his full back, missed countless shirt pulling offences, accused a player of diving and then awarded another a free kick for the same thing seconds later and so it goes on. Also apparently turned up with a sun dial to keep time only to find that it gets dark in Barnsley about 6pm at the moment – hence a first half that he said he would extend by two minutes ended up running to 50. Either that or he wanted to see what happened with their corners, bless him.
His only other QPR fixture was back in his first season on the list in 2002 at Wigan. The R’s secured a 1-1 draw but would have done better had they been awarded a first minute penalty when Andy Thomson was blatantly chopped down in the box. Afterwards Ian Holloway blamed the referee’s inexperience and nerves for him not giving the decision.
Ilderton, like Oliver Langford at the weekend, has very lenient stats this season. He’s booked just 38, and sent off one player, in 16 appointments so far. Six yellow cards at Notts County v York is his biggest haul this season by a long way.
Last season he showed 98 yellows and two reds in 31 matches, which included Blackburn’s 2-1 win at Sheffield Wednesday which was his last Rovers appointment.
Championship >>> Gavin Ward steps up to the Championship for Brentford v Middlesbrough. Best of luck with that guys.
Pictures – Action Images
Get two free £10 bets on Queens Park Rangers v Preston North End (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.
Photo: Action Images
Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
You need to login in order to post your comments
Queens Park Rangers Polls