| What's "wrong" with Christianity? 20:17 - Aug 3 with 36440 views | Davillin |
What's "wrong" with Christianity?
N.B. In my opinion, it's not what's "wrong" with Christianity, but rather what's wrong with certain dismissive analyses of Christianity.
Everything that's "wrong" with Christianity is not about Christ and his teaching, but is about matters tangential to his teaching.
First and foremost, the Old Testament. Eliminate all of it and all of the hate-filled attacks on the thousands of sometimes imaginary and sometimes at least partly imaginary, and this would be a quieter place, and a quieter message board.
Second, eliminate all of the mythical elements like angels singing on high, and three wise men, and immaculate conception, and virgin birth, etc, etc, etc.
Third, eliminate all of the happy horsesh!t that goes on within the formalized churches -- especially the Catholic Church -- everything from fanciful non-Biblical embellishments and sometimes exceedingly silly rules and dogma, to long-past historical peccadilloes and worse, long-past political, economic, and military outrages.
Fourth, eliminate all of the excesses in wealth, ostentatious wealth, and pseudo regal trappings.
Fifth, do not be put off by Christ's speaking of Heaven and Hell, and the Father, but remember that these are images fully understood by his unsophisticated audience as images of one kind or another, and are not granite-hard reality.
Not one of the things I describe above has anything significant to do with either Christ or his teachings. When you ignore or eliminate all of those things, you will have the freedom to get to the heart of his teaching.
Although you can be richly rewarded by searching through the New Testament, reading all of the red typeface (which is a standard indication of the words of Christ), you really need go no further than the Sermon on the Mount, where, in essence, he gives an explication of The Ten Commandments, which alone give anyone who wants it a guide to a moral life.
http://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Matthew-5_7/
The "pixies and fairies" so beloved of those who wish to denigrate either the Bible, religion itself, or just Christianity, were put in there as a means of explaining astoundingly complex concepts to people who were completely ill-equipped to understand them without these "teaching aids."
Anyone who is, or pretends to be, intelligent and well-read, should know to move immediately beyond these images and get to the heart of the teaching.
I not only admit, but trumpet aloud, the fact that it is far too easy to be dismissive based on tangentials, and difficult to get past them to the meaning, and moreover sometimes difficult beyond some persons' intellectual capacity.
In my opinion, it's better simply to not get involved in these discussions than to try to fight against the closed mind, and especially the mind that is closed because of non-essential and inconsequential side issues.
|  |
| |  |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 20:30 - Aug 3 with 16211 views | Drizzle |
One problem surely is that some Christians think that belief is enough. Unfortunatley what really matters is how you act. If you want to know what someone believes, look at their actions. Its all very well saying you believe but if you treat people like crap then that doesn't tally. Going to church once a week doesn't make you a christian. Living selflessly makes you a christian.
The fact is Christianity doesn't work because not enough people(who supposedly practice it) understand what it is to be Christian. Back to the individual again, as usual. |  | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 20:57 - Aug 3 with 16102 views | JackoBoostardo |
you could just try reading one of the several threads already here - as these more than answer your points. |  |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 23:46 - Aug 3 with 16114 views | epaul |
It's all bollux |  |
| The hair and the beard have gone I am now conforming to society, tis a sad day
The b*stards are coming back though |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 00:54 - Aug 4 with 16096 views | Davillin |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 23:46 - Aug 3 by epaul |
It's all bollux |
In my opinion, you do not do yourself justice by one crude dismissive phrase, in light of the fact that many of the greatest intellects of the past 2,000 years have studied it -- and thousands of times more deeply than you have -- and written some of the most important religious prose ever.
These great philosopher-writers deal almost exclusively with what Christ taught, and not the tangentials I name in the original post.
Reading your posts about religion recently leads me to the conclusion that you have read not a word of any of those great philosophers. It also appears to me that you did not even read the original post.
I am not being in the least rude or dismissive, but a post like yours is worthless. | |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 01:33 - Aug 4 with 16083 views | epaul |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 00:54 - Aug 4 by Davillin |
In my opinion, you do not do yourself justice by one crude dismissive phrase, in light of the fact that many of the greatest intellects of the past 2,000 years have studied it -- and thousands of times more deeply than you have -- and written some of the most important religious prose ever.
These great philosopher-writers deal almost exclusively with what Christ taught, and not the tangentials I name in the original post.
Reading your posts about religion recently leads me to the conclusion that you have read not a word of any of those great philosophers. It also appears to me that you did not even read the original post.
I am not being in the least rude or dismissive, but a post like yours is worthless. |
TBH I couldn't give a flying f*** and I'll come back to my original statement that it's all a load of bollux. You say christ taught, hang on he's just some imaginary bloke, so that says a lot that you put an imaginery person in that context when he never existed....delusional...and I'll say it again great philosophers what religious ones....one word bullsh1t
Please be aware whilst I have a disdain for religion, if an individual has comfort in it good for them just don't push it on me | |
| The hair and the beard have gone I am now conforming to society, tis a sad day
The b*stards are coming back though |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 02:05 - Aug 4 with 16078 views | Davillin |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 01:33 - Aug 4 by epaul |
TBH I couldn't give a flying f*** and I'll come back to my original statement that it's all a load of bollux. You say christ taught, hang on he's just some imaginary bloke, so that says a lot that you put an imaginery person in that context when he never existed....delusional...and I'll say it again great philosophers what religious ones....one word bullsh1t
Please be aware whilst I have a disdain for religion, if an individual has comfort in it good for them just don't push it on me |
Shhhhhhh. You'll have a stroke or a coronary. It's not worth it.
History -- many historians, and contemporary and near-contemporary historians -- say he did exist. Even the Koran acknowledges it.
Who knows? Some day History might say that you existed, too. And someone will dismiss it as "bollux" or bullsh1t.
Ah, ignominy undeserved!
[p.s. I missed the posts where someone "pushed religion on you."] | |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 02:58 - Aug 4 with 16069 views | phact0rri |
What are you on about? what makes people angry at Christians? or what makes people not want to believe in Christianity? |  |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 07:46 - Aug 4 with 16036 views | dailew |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 00:54 - Aug 4 by Davillin |
In my opinion, you do not do yourself justice by one crude dismissive phrase, in light of the fact that many of the greatest intellects of the past 2,000 years have studied it -- and thousands of times more deeply than you have -- and written some of the most important religious prose ever.
These great philosopher-writers deal almost exclusively with what Christ taught, and not the tangentials I name in the original post.
Reading your posts about religion recently leads me to the conclusion that you have read not a word of any of those great philosophers. It also appears to me that you did not even read the original post.
I am not being in the least rude or dismissive, but a post like yours is worthless. |
Judge not, that ye be not judged. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 08:07 - Aug 4 with 15950 views | JackoBoostardo |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 02:05 - Aug 4 by Davillin |
Shhhhhhh. You'll have a stroke or a coronary. It's not worth it.
History -- many historians, and contemporary and near-contemporary historians -- say he did exist. Even the Koran acknowledges it.
Who knows? Some day History might say that you existed, too. And someone will dismiss it as "bollux" or bullsh1t.
Ah, ignominy undeserved!
[p.s. I missed the posts where someone "pushed religion on you."] |
Name these historians along with their credentials then... As there Is no proof he existed other than a few vague references relating to a person where some have managed to add 2+3 and made 78,000!
At least back up your claim! | |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 08:39 - Aug 4 with 15992 views | jackb |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 00:54 - Aug 4 by Davillin |
In my opinion, you do not do yourself justice by one crude dismissive phrase, in light of the fact that many of the greatest intellects of the past 2,000 years have studied it -- and thousands of times more deeply than you have -- and written some of the most important religious prose ever.
These great philosopher-writers deal almost exclusively with what Christ taught, and not the tangentials I name in the original post.
Reading your posts about religion recently leads me to the conclusion that you have read not a word of any of those great philosophers. It also appears to me that you did not even read the original post.
I am not being in the least rude or dismissive, but a post like yours is worthless. |
Well actually you are being exactly that! |  | | |
| What's on 08:43 - Aug 4 with 16000 views | Drizzle |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 08:39 - Aug 4 by jackb |
Well actually you are being exactly that! |
Anyone who deplores homophobia should also deplore theophobia. Paul has long expressed his disgust at some peoples attitudes towards homosexuals, yet he displays similar irrational hatred towards religion. Its almost funny. [Post edited 4 Aug 2014 8:53]
| | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:04 - Aug 4 with 15973 views | phact0rri |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 08:07 - Aug 4 by JackoBoostardo |
Name these historians along with their credentials then... As there Is no proof he existed other than a few vague references relating to a person where some have managed to add 2+3 and made 78,000!
At least back up your claim! |
Actually, Senator Tacitus ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacitus ) wrote a small passage about the execution of one Jesus Christ, in one of his Annals. Historically we take this a valid record. It goes into detail and if we take one of the greatest Roman historians known.
In context if we are to take Tacitus' account he could have been included in the mass executions of christians after they set fire to parts of rome, that burned for five days (ala the great fire or rome).
*shrugs* The knowledge of Jesus Christ existing isn't at all confused in history. We know he existed, and if its heavily shown in many roman records that he was a bit of a rebel rouser. | |
| |
| What's on 09:04 - Aug 4 with 15971 views | epaul |
| What's on 08:43 - Aug 4 by Drizzle |
Anyone who deplores homophobia should also deplore theophobia. Paul has long expressed his disgust at some peoples attitudes towards homosexuals, yet he displays similar irrational hatred towards religion. Its almost funny. [Post edited 4 Aug 2014 8:53]
|
It's the theory of religion I guess I hate not individuals | |
| The hair and the beard have gone I am now conforming to society, tis a sad day
The b*stards are coming back though |
| |
| What's on 09:39 - Aug 4 with 15946 views | Drizzle |
| What's on 09:04 - Aug 4 by epaul |
It's the theory of religion I guess I hate not individuals |
The theory of religion is actually to treat every one better. Its just that humans seem to make even something as positive as that into a cause of yet more conflict. Its not the idea that's bad, just our inability to implement it. As has been mentioned several times communism looks great in theory. It falls down when you try and make it a lifestyle though as human self will has a tendency to creep back in at the most in-opportune of moments. | | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:41 - Aug 4 with 15945 views | Drizzle |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 07:46 - Aug 4 by dailew |
Judge not, that ye be not judged. |
Or in your case, post not lest you be judged. Easy to hide behind arrows. On the evidence of what little you post, probably a good idea to keep it that way. | | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:54 - Aug 4 with 15875 views | perchrockjack |
If nothing else it's a very eloquent op. |  |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 11:48 - Aug 4 with 15876 views | JJJack |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:04 - Aug 4 by phact0rri |
Actually, Senator Tacitus ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacitus ) wrote a small passage about the execution of one Jesus Christ, in one of his Annals. Historically we take this a valid record. It goes into detail and if we take one of the greatest Roman historians known.
In context if we are to take Tacitus' account he could have been included in the mass executions of christians after they set fire to parts of rome, that burned for five days (ala the great fire or rome).
*shrugs* The knowledge of Jesus Christ existing isn't at all confused in history. We know he existed, and if its heavily shown in many roman records that he was a bit of a rebel rouser. |
I'm glad you posted this link. According to you it is "evidence" that Jesus Christ existed. When even a cursory read of it raises far more questions than answers. The link suggests that Christ was perhaps crucified or set upon by dogs....but Tacitus wrote this in c.116 A.D. and states it occurred in 64 A.D.
I had always thought "Jesus" died in 32 or 33 A.D. .....as that was his age at the time. Perhaps I just misunderstood this point. I'm sorry, but I have read a lot of evidence to suggest there is no certainty that a" Jesus Christ" Esq. existed in that area at that particular time. The origins of Christianity are highly questionable and were "agreed" upon some centuries later I understand. In other words, conveniently made up to control the masses. It worked. Until people developed the intelligence to understand the deviousness of it all. |  | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 11:51 - Aug 4 with 15876 views | jackonicko |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:54 - Aug 4 by perchrockjack |
If nothing else it's a very eloquent op. |
I agree with Dav that some fellow called something like Jesus existed. Whether he was the son of the Big Guy is another matter.
My problem with Christianity can be summed up in three little words. "Spread the word". That has been translated into some of the most abhorrent human behaviour of all history. |  | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:21 - Aug 4 with 15848 views | jackb |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 09:54 - Aug 4 by perchrockjack |
If nothing else it's a very eloquent op. |
he does like to be | | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:26 - Aug 4 with 15851 views | Darran |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:21 - Aug 4 by jackb |
he does like to be |
Here's a serious question for you Jackb.
If you profess to be this enlightened leftie like yoh do on here why do you constantly try to ridicule the OP?
Serious question.
Just wondering. |  |
| |
| What's on 12:26 - Aug 4 with 15840 views | jackb |
| What's on 08:43 - Aug 4 by Drizzle |
Anyone who deplores homophobia should also deplore theophobia. Paul has long expressed his disgust at some peoples attitudes towards homosexuals, yet he displays similar irrational hatred towards religion. Its almost funny. [Post edited 4 Aug 2014 8:53]
|
Religion is a choice, sexuality is not;
I don't get LGBT people knocking me up of a morning trying to convert me on the doorstep
Their views and actions are not affecting what I can/can't do;
You don't get LGBT people warping and manipulating the minds of the young ,the weak and the vulnerable.
No real comparison, IMHO :)
Nothing irrational in disliking religion, it's the exact opposite! | | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:35 - Aug 4 with 15836 views | JJJack |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:26 - Aug 4 by Darran |
Here's a serious question for you Jackb.
If you profess to be this enlightened leftie like yoh do on here why do you constantly try to ridicule the OP?
Serious question.
Just wondering. |
"In my opinion, it's better simply to not get involved in these discussions than to try to fight against the closed mind, and especially the mind that is closed because of non-essential and inconsequential side issues."
I'll tell you what I ridicule Daz.......look at the above paragraph which is the final paragraph of the OP. Dav puts a pretty reasonable post on here which is thought-provoking if not obviously biased. But then ends the post with a "and don't bother disagreeing with me because I'm not going to bother discussing it if you do" comment. That's about as ridiculous and pointless as you can get in terms of starting up a , er, "discussion". | | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:50 - Aug 4 with 15829 views | Darran |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:35 - Aug 4 by JJJack |
"In my opinion, it's better simply to not get involved in these discussions than to try to fight against the closed mind, and especially the mind that is closed because of non-essential and inconsequential side issues."
I'll tell you what I ridicule Daz.......look at the above paragraph which is the final paragraph of the OP. Dav puts a pretty reasonable post on here which is thought-provoking if not obviously biased. But then ends the post with a "and don't bother disagreeing with me because I'm not going to bother discussing it if you do" comment. That's about as ridiculous and pointless as you can get in terms of starting up a , er, "discussion". |
I wasn't talking about just this post J though I'm not disagreeing with you I'm talking about Jackb in general. | |
| |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:57 - Aug 4 with 15811 views | Liam |
Re OP:
I disagree with ignoring the OT. If you ignore that massive context very little of the NT makes sense - for example why was there a need for a messiah? Humanity in chaos, atonement, Judges, Kings, Solomon, David and the need for an eternal perfect king.
Secondly ignoring the supernatural stuff is folly. You need to take it all otherwise you're believing in an idol not a sovereign god - sovereign over natural laws and able do alter them at will.
I just realised he's also most probably blocked me so can't read this oh well |  | | |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 13:04 - Aug 4 with 15806 views | JJJack |
| What's "wrong" with Christianity? on 12:50 - Aug 4 by Darran |
I wasn't talking about just this post J though I'm not disagreeing with you I'm talking about Jackb in general. |
Fair enough. My memory is not good enough to remember what people usually post. I can't even remember what I post myself TBH  | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
