| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. 15:16 - Feb 3 with 2684 views | A_Fans_Dad |
Taking a settled side that had not lost in 5 games they promote Cullen, their top scorer to the 1st team and then make 6 other changes to that settled side.
The changes included 2 triallists in defence, who didn't seem to do too well and Garrick who played the first half after coming back from injury. |  | | |  |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:27 - Feb 3 with 2646 views | Flashberryjack |
The loss could have, and probably should have been much, much heavier.
Poor display IMO, sad thing is they get a dose of the bad passes as soon as they get anywhere near the opposition's goal area, very much like the senior team. |  |
| |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:32 - Feb 3 with 2626 views | Thornburyswan |
Whilst I do understand your very valid points I guess it comes down to how the club/Cooper see the value of the U23s - if it is too maximise their winning & gain maximum points/cup wins etc you are spot on.
However you could look at it from the perspective of (1) we have another load of change come the summer & bringing trialists in early (rather than wait until May/June) might be a decent call & with both MvdH & Nauts likely to leave plus Wilmot & maybe Guehi returning to their clubs we might need a defender or two & (2) if Garrick is to impact our last 12/14 games he needs some playing time. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:41 - Feb 3 with 2612 views | A_Fans_Dad |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:32 - Feb 3 by Thornburyswan |
Whilst I do understand your very valid points I guess it comes down to how the club/Cooper see the value of the U23s - if it is too maximise their winning & gain maximum points/cup wins etc you are spot on.
However you could look at it from the perspective of (1) we have another load of change come the summer & bringing trialists in early (rather than wait until May/June) might be a decent call & with both MvdH & Nauts likely to leave plus Wilmot & maybe Guehi returning to their clubs we might need a defender or two & (2) if Garrick is to impact our last 12/14 games he needs some playing time. |
That is all very well, but what does it do to the morale of the U23s team?
Changing over half of a winning team is not good when it results in such a disastrous outcome.
By the way Cooper does not run that team, or the U18s. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:44 - Feb 3 with 2608 views | TimTtam |
I only just realised there's no relegation from PL 2 Div 2. So there's no real need for the U23s to earn points. They'd be slaughtered in Division 1. Bringing in trialists is a good idea.
It could be worse. Sunderland U23s are on 1 point after 16 games... |  |
| |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:59 - Feb 3 with 2578 views | jack247 |
If Cullen is now going to be a regular senior squad player, then the under 23s have done their job. I get that it’s positive for them to win games and play with a consistent squad, but their main objective is to get players to the level they can play for the first team.
If they are missing their best striker because he is now considered part of the first team, are giving minutes to another first team squad player who is coming back from injury and a couple of players have to miss out because we’re having a look at players we may want to sign, surely that’s a good thing? | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 16:03 - Feb 3 with 2572 views | jasper_T |
Strange lineup today, with only one central midfielder in Dan Williams (just back from 4 months out) and forwards Cooper and Jones-Thomas deployed as the Byers and Gallagher either side of him. Can't say it worked at all, should have stuck with the two holders like we normally do (Tom Price or Kenko starting alongside Williams in Evans' absence).
Then on the left we had two fullbacks in Blake and the trialist Aina, who took a half each in their preferred position.
Celina looked a tidy enough player but RB not exactly a position we're short on with Rushesha and Bevan coming through. Aina was poor. Gudjohnsen's got nothing to his game to suggest investing in the family name was worth it. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 16:17 - Feb 3 with 2544 views | Thornburyswan |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 15:41 - Feb 3 by A_Fans_Dad |
That is all very well, but what does it do to the morale of the U23s team?
Changing over half of a winning team is not good when it results in such a disastrous outcome.
By the way Cooper does not run that team, or the U18s. |
I know he doesn’t run the younger sides but clearly he’ll have input either directly or via Birch/Leon etc, agree on the confidence point but again depends on what messages are being delivered to the players. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 16:30 - Feb 3 with 2500 views | jasper_T |
Without jumping to too many conclusions it did look like more of a Cooper-ish shape today. So maybe he is having input with the interim managers. That old "kids should play like the seniors to prepare them better" common sense chestnut that isn't so simple in reality. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 19:52 - Feb 3 with 2282 views | Kilkennyjack |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 16:03 - Feb 3 by jasper_T |
Strange lineup today, with only one central midfielder in Dan Williams (just back from 4 months out) and forwards Cooper and Jones-Thomas deployed as the Byers and Gallagher either side of him. Can't say it worked at all, should have stuck with the two holders like we normally do (Tom Price or Kenko starting alongside Williams in Evans' absence).
Then on the left we had two fullbacks in Blake and the trialist Aina, who took a half each in their preferred position.
Celina looked a tidy enough player but RB not exactly a position we're short on with Rushesha and Bevan coming through. Aina was poor. Gudjohnsen's got nothing to his game to suggest investing in the family name was worth it. |
‘Investing in the family name’ ..... ouch !! |  |
| Beware of the Risen People
|
| |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 11:01 - Feb 4 with 1981 views | whiterock |
If we wanted to win every game do you think Bedna would be staring for Swindon, no, he'd be between the sticks for the 23's, loaning him out gets him far more ready for first team duties and that's what the 23's are there for. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 11:34 - Feb 4 with 1940 views | Badlands |
If we want to keep attracting good quality players in the Academy the academy needs to offer two things
a) passport to regular first team football (at Swansea in top two leagues, on loan or from a transfer) which it has been very successful at.
b) having successful 'unders' teams which we have not had of some time (partly because of 'a'.
I would like to see the strongest under 23 team compete in the next round of the International Cup but I suspect it won't happen. |  |
| |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 14:30 - Feb 4 with 1834 views | Blue_Blood |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 11:34 - Feb 4 by Badlands |
If we want to keep attracting good quality players in the Academy the academy needs to offer two things
a) passport to regular first team football (at Swansea in top two leagues, on loan or from a transfer) which it has been very successful at.
b) having successful 'unders' teams which we have not had of some time (partly because of 'a'.
I would like to see the strongest under 23 team compete in the next round of the International Cup but I suspect it won't happen. |
A) is far more important than B) | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 16:38 - Feb 4 with 1750 views | glanmORJa_k |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 14:30 - Feb 4 by Blue_Blood |
A) is far more important than B) |
Take away the fact that players like Cullen and Jack Evans are out on loan, who exactly would you put in the team that in your opinion would be the best players available to play in the International Cup competition. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 17:34 - Feb 4 with 1701 views | jasper_T |
Less local lads in that team than the u23s.
Rough week so far for Webb in goal. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 17:44 - Feb 4 with 1689 views | 34dfgdf54 |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 17:34 - Feb 4 by jasper_T |
Less local lads in that team than the u23s.
Rough week so far for Webb in goal. |
What’s he like?
Went through same college as I did, know a few boys who know him well so like to keep an eye on how he’s getting on. |  | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 19:25 - Feb 4 with 1638 views | glanmORJa_k |
Webb was the only player who came out of the game with any credibility yesterday. A very good prospect who is being played in the 18's and 23's. His height is not the benchmark these days for keepers, but what he hasn't got in his all round movement is lead feet. | | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 19:53 - Feb 4 with 1620 views | TenbySwan |
If Brewster and Cullen get injured looks like we are a bit exposed. |  | | |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 20:03 - Feb 4 with 1615 views | 34dfgdf54 |
| U23s thrashed 4:0 by Newcastle and no wonder. on 19:53 - Feb 4 by TenbySwan |
If Brewster and Cullen get injured looks like we are a bit exposed. |
Ayew will go up there most likely | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.