Queens Park Rangers 1 v 1 Stoke City
EFL Championship
Saturday, 23rd November 2024 Kick-off 15:00

Voting is OPEN. Click here to submit your votes.

Paul Nardi	6.4
Jimmy Dunne	4.7
Steve Cook	5.7
Liam Morrison	6.1
Harrison Ashby	5.7
Jonathan Varane	5.9
Sam Field	5.7
Paul Smyth	5.3
Nicolas Madsen	5.3
Koki Saito	7.1
Zan Celar	2.7

Morgan Fox	4.9
Alfie Lloyd	6.0
Kieran Morgan	5.3
Kenneth Paal	5.0

Referee	6.6
Match Rating	5.9

Your Queens Park Rangers v Stoke City Match Reports

MelakaRanger added 18:07 - Nov 23

Having awarded my votes I see that Celar has an average of 1.6. How can anyone have given him more than 1. He deserves zero

HarryLondon added 18:41 - Nov 23

Celar is useless and Marti keeps playing him! Alfie Lloyd has to start in Cardiff and Celar needs to be sold in January- he is not up to the Championship. Neither is Madsen, Anderson or Ashby.

MickB added 20:10 - Nov 23

I would keep them all and flog Jackanourry. Literally. His data-driven masterplan has inflicted these expensive inadequates on us. (I don't include Anderson or young Ashby in this).

Geoff78 added 16:40 - Nov 24

It seems something's wrong between Cifuentes and Nourry and the crowd's support for Marti shows where the fans loyalty lies.

A word of sympathy for Nourry. He shouldn't have been put in this position, without adequate support. However clever he is he can't have the experience to do a job like this without advice/mentoring from an 'old hand'.

As things stand you'd probably say the summer signings consist of 2 successes (Nardi + Saito), 3 probably ok (Varane, Morgan, Morrison) + 3 maybe ok given time (Dembele, Bennie, Ashby). So far Celar, Madsen (although he was better yesterday) and Santos have not impressed.

Data is great but a DoF needs more. He's clever so I'd hope he'll learn. He should start by stating his support for Marti and building a good relationship with him. But he may be feeling heat from the owners, which will make things difficult for him.

tsbains64 added 07:10 - Nov 25

High rating for the ref, just to annoy the wingeing Stoke fans Thought he did a reasonable job