Miller referes Wednesday game again Thursday, 5th Nov 2009 15:02 For the second successive season County Durham official Nigel Miller is the man in the middle for our trip to Sheffield Wednesday.
Sheffield Wednesday v QPR
Referee – Nigel Miller (Durham)
Assistants – Akers (Norfolk) and Graham (Essex)
Fourth Official – Madley (Essex)
Last season Rangers were beaten 1-0 on a freezing cold Tuesday night in a game where Martin Rowlands missed a first half penalty. Miller did top the LFW referee league for a performance at Wolves a few years back but has been very hit and miss with us since then. The authorities seem to like the idea of having Miller referee QPR in Sheffield as he did our narrow 2-1 defeat at Bramall Lane in 2007/08 as well.
So far this season Miller has shown 34 yellow cards (2.42 a game) and four reds in 14 matches. His biggest haul in a single game is six yellows in an early season encounter between Sheff Utd and Leicester – a physical match up if ever there was one. Six of his games so far have been in the Championship where he has shown 15 yellows and one red, slightly above his average.
Last season he showed 76 yellows (2.235 a game) and six reds in 34 matches. That included a 0-0 draw between Rangers at Plymouth at Loftus Road and the 1-0 defeat at Hillsborough. His average rating of 4.5 placed him 33rd on the referee league last season.
Referee: Nigel Miller (Durham) 5 Good to see the cards kept in his pocket apart from Grant who deserved his. The penalty was a good decision as well put apart from that he seemed to make a number of perplexing decisions – allowing Clarke to consistently foul opponents without punishment, giving hand ball decisions when they were fired at a player from a yard away and then allowing play to go on when players deliberately controlled the ball with their arms. It was a strange performance really, very frustrating and inconsistent at times. LFW Sheff Wed Match Report
Referee: Nigel Miller (Durham) 4 Eccentric. Gave free kicks for nothing very much, waved play on to assaults on Helguson and Balanta to name but two. Also had that annoying habit of awarding the defending team a free kick whenever there was a question mark over the award of a corner – Plymouth seemed to cotton on to this and spent the whole second half appealing enthusiastically for a goal kick for even the most blatant of corners and then being rewarded with a free kick for some offence or other only seen by Mr Miller. All in all a right pain in the arse, all 23 people on the pitch on Saturday were very poor. LFW Plymouth Match Report
In 2007/08 he refereed one QPR game, a 2-1 defeat at Sheff Utd. That game was marked by a controversial incident in stoppage time when Akos Buzsaky seemed to have a potential equaliser punched off the goal line by defender Matt Kilgallon but no penalty was awarded. The replays were inconclusive. Miller’s rating of five placed him 22nd on the referee league.
Referee: Nigel Miller (Durham) 5 Very hard mark to give here because looking at the replays I don’t think it’s possible to decide definitively if Kilgallon handled the ball on the line or not. I’ve spoken to QPR fans who swear blind he did, and others who say he didn’t. The players seemed certain he did, although one thing I did notice on the highlights was the immediate reaction of the QPR fans directly behind the goal wasn’t to appeal for handball. Over the course of the game he seemed to get a number of decisions wrong, and the bald linesman going towards the away end was absolutely useless. Absolutely bloody useless. He looked at the referee before giving even the most simple of throw in decisions – you have a mind of your own you stupid little man use it. Wrongly disallowed Sharp’s goal in the first half but kept the flag down and allowed Hulse to race through on goal when he was clearly offside. Poor referee, terrible linesman, lethal combination. LFW Sheff Utd Match Report
His lowest mark for a QPR performance came the season before, 2006/07, when he sent off Lee Cook in a 2-1 defeat against Hull at the KC Stadium. His rating of three placed him 31st on the referee league.
Ref: N Miller (Co Durham) 3 QPR Rivals Referee of the Year? If we'd given him a medal I'd like to choke him to death with it tonight. Shambolic display from start to finish. Gave some ridiculous decisions in QPR's favour for the first hour and then after failing to card Kanyuka for the worst challenge of the season so far on Forster set about awarding everything to Hull. Failed to award a blatant penalty when Cook was tripped and then sent him off for complaining. Allowed time wasting, stopped play for one head injury and played on for another, carded for something and then didn't even award a free kick for the same thing moments later. Lost it big time, a horrific performance. LFW Hull Match Report
And then in 2005/06, the complete opposite, a near perfect performance in a defeat at Wolves that saw him top the table.
Ref: N Miller (Co Durham) – 9 The Wolves fans were going a bit mad with him but they do that with every ref! Miller could have been awarded a penalty but it was a fifty fifty call and in letting the game flow and keeping the cards in his pocket this guy is a good bet to top our referee league come May. One point deducted for an appalling effort at a moustache. LFW Wolves Match Report
QPR haven’t won in five matches with this referee then, but they did beat Burnley 3-0 with him in charge in 2004/05.
Elsewhere this weekend Lee Probert is the man trusted to keep control of the South Wales derby between Cardiff and Swansea on Saturday lunch time. Probert is a risky appointment, as a card happy and picky referee who has already made some key mistakes in games this season. Premiership referee Phil Dowd is the man in the middle on Monday night for what is sure to be a fiery encounter between Barnsley and Sheff Utd – although Chris Morgan’s one match ban is handily timed for the people charged with keeping that game under control.
Photo courtesy of refworld.com.
Photo: Action Images via Reuters