| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? 08:44 - Oct 28 with 1899 views | yankranger |
Thought Green was great last night. I would have voted McCarthy after Liverpool, not so sure now.
A huge positive that we have both of these players. |  | | |  |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:06 - Oct 28 with 1878 views | ElHoop |
We shouldn't fiddle around - let this team settle down for a few games and make the odd tactical change here and there. |  | | |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:09 - Oct 28 with 1862 views | Bluce_Ree |
Green is the king. |  |
| ALL THINGS ARE POSSIBLE THROUGH MARTI THE REDEEMER WHO STRENGTHENS ME. |
| |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:24 - Oct 28 with 1842 views | robith |
While Green's triple save was tremendous keeping and boosted his confidence, his distribution was poor and a big step down from McCarthy, and he made some really questionable decisions early on.
Personally I think McCarthy should've retained his place, but we probably have to stick with Green now |  | | |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:30 - Oct 28 with 1827 views | Pommyhoop |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:24 - Oct 28 by robith |
While Green's triple save was tremendous keeping and boosted his confidence, his distribution was poor and a big step down from McCarthy, and he made some really questionable decisions early on.
Personally I think McCarthy should've retained his place, but we probably have to stick with Green now |
Agree with this. If McCarthy was not injured I feel he shoulve retained his place.I feel no.body should just waltze back into the team if there replacement is playing well.
I dont believe Barton should just turn up and kick Henry out of the team when he's fit either.
Do what other teams do ,introduce them as subs ,make them work to be picked.
I hope RIO never sets foot on a pitch wearing our hoops ever again but thats another thread.. |  |
| |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:38 - Oct 28 with 1818 views | ElHoop |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:30 - Oct 28 by Pommyhoop |
Agree with this. If McCarthy was not injured I feel he shoulve retained his place.I feel no.body should just waltze back into the team if there replacement is playing well.
I dont believe Barton should just turn up and kick Henry out of the team when he's fit either.
Do what other teams do ,introduce them as subs ,make them work to be picked.
I hope RIO never sets foot on a pitch wearing our hoops ever again but thats another thread.. |
OK so McCarthy shouldn't waltz back into the team now that he is injured? | | | |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:45 - Oct 28 with 1794 views | ozexile |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:38 - Oct 28 by ElHoop |
OK so McCarthy shouldn't waltz back into the team now that he is injured? |
Green made an incredible save in the first half. A cracking volley was hit at him and bounced just before it reached him and he caught it superbly. Top night for him. | | | |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:49 - Oct 28 with 1780 views | bosh67 |
To be fair Green was in top form and the triple save was probably the best I have seen at Loftus Road since Royston's miracle save from Akinbiyi a number of years back. |  |
| |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:50 - Oct 28 with 1777 views | Pommyhoop |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:38 - Oct 28 by ElHoop |
OK so McCarthy shouldn't waltz back into the team now that he is injured? |
Nope I meant he should've been picked if he was'nt injured..After his Liverpool performance .
Unfortunately for him he got injured and now Greeno had a brilliant game he shouldnt be picked ahead of Greeno. Pressures on Green now to perform which is good for us.
Healthy competition for places did no one any harm. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:56 - Oct 28 with 1762 views | ElHoop |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:50 - Oct 28 by Pommyhoop |
Nope I meant he should've been picked if he was'nt injured..After his Liverpool performance .
Unfortunately for him he got injured and now Greeno had a brilliant game he shouldnt be picked ahead of Greeno. Pressures on Green now to perform which is good for us.
Healthy competition for places did no one any harm. |
I've seen McCarthy a couple of times and am a bit concerned that he's overrated by some, but maybe I just saw him on the wrong days. He's definitely had some weaknesses but he may have fixed them. Too early to say, but i wouldn't want to deflate Green or at least that's to be avoided until we see how far McCarthy can be inflated. In a way, it helps if one or other of them gets injured every now and then. As someone has said, Green's own distribution wasn't too great last night. | | | |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 10:04 - Oct 28 with 1744 views | simmo |
It's such a shame for McCarthy, has his chance to make the No1 shirt his own, does well and looks in line to do that, but misses out last minute. Green, to his credit, took the pressure of someone else wanting his spot on board and produced a strong performance including those saves to retain the all too rare clean sheet...
Although I think McCarthy is better and our long term option, it should be Greens place to lose now and big Alex will have to wait again.... |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 10:12 - Oct 28 with 1735 views | CiderwithRsie |
| Refresh of previous question - McCarthy or Green? on 09:38 - Oct 28 by ElHoop |
OK so McCarthy shouldn't waltz back into the team now that he is injured? |
That would be my position.
I'd have kept McCarthy in if he was fit, but he wasn't so Green played. Green did well so he keeps his place unless he's not fit or loses form.
We have two good keepers, both seem to have the right attitude. The competition is good for both of them but they each need to know they get a fair crack of the whip, otherwise one of them will think there's no point in trying. And swapping to and fro without a really good reason is very unsettling both for the keepers an the defence in front of them. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
