Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Gaffer on today's defeat 18:46 - Dec 13 with 1162 viewsbosh67



Fair assessment really.

Never knowingly right.
Poll: How long before new signings become quivering wrecks of the players they were?

0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 20:31 - Dec 13 with 1051 viewsQPRJill

Why didn` t he go with 3 in midfield? He surely has to take some of the blame for this one. Hayden can`t be very pleased tonight.
0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 23:29 - Dec 13 with 893 viewsstainrods_elbow

He seems reasonably equainimous, and even chipper, having been out-played and out-thought/prepared. My one mild curiosity was the timing of 'it's been a good week' mantra (2.01) - it's like product placement, isn't it? Apparently, the analysis is 'simple' - they were miles better - and so there are 'no complaints'. That's all right then - no need for any kind of debrief or struggle up a learning curve (especially if it's mid-week and we have to get on an exhausting bus for a couple of hours first)!
[Post edited 13 Dec 23:32]

Poll: What do you expect from the Charlton game?

-2
Gaffer on today's defeat on 00:15 - Dec 14 with 900 viewsSydneyRs

Why does there always have to be someone to "blame"?

They're a stronger squad, in great form, at home. Hardly a shock outcome.
[Post edited 14 Dec 0:16]
7
Gaffer on today's defeat on 00:28 - Dec 14 with 838 viewsstainrods_elbow

It's not about blaming, it's about intelligent critique, and learning - as the manager himself says - about how we could and should strive to do better.

Poll: What do you expect from the Charlton game?

1
Gaffer on today's defeat on 02:17 - Dec 14 with 842 viewsSydneyRs

Gaffer on today's defeat on 00:28 - Dec 14 by stainrods_elbow

It's not about blaming, it's about intelligent critique, and learning - as the manager himself says - about how we could and should strive to do better.


I'm referring to those who claim that if only this or that player was picked or this or that formation was used, we wouldn't have lost. After every defeat. The ones that somehow are more qualified than the manager.

We are learning and improving, I think that's obvious. We also have several players and a manager who are new to this division.
5
Gaffer on today's defeat (n/t) on 15:59 - Dec 14 with 660 viewsQPRJill

He didn`t do anything to try and change the direction of the game in the first half. That was a bid odd, imo.
[Post edited 14 Dec 16:04]
0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 16:24 - Dec 14 with 624 viewsWilkinswatercarrier

Gaffer on today's defeat on 02:17 - Dec 14 by SydneyRs

I'm referring to those who claim that if only this or that player was picked or this or that formation was used, we wouldn't have lost. After every defeat. The ones that somehow are more qualified than the manager.

We are learning and improving, I think that's obvious. We also have several players and a manager who are new to this division.


Not sure that's really fair. I think we would have lost regardless of formation etc, but we should make it as difficult as possible for the opposition.

Personally I think JS got it wrong and should have gone three in midfield, something pointed out in Clives pre match writeup.

Poll: How is Nourry cooking so far ? 🤣

1
Gaffer on today's defeat on 16:55 - Dec 14 with 576 viewsbosh67

Gaffer on today's defeat on 16:24 - Dec 14 by Wilkinswatercarrier

Not sure that's really fair. I think we would have lost regardless of formation etc, but we should make it as difficult as possible for the opposition.

Personally I think JS got it wrong and should have gone three in midfield, something pointed out in Clives pre match writeup.


Possibly playing Varane and Hayden as a holding 2 in front of the back 4 in away games would help us cope in midfield in some away games. That does potentially mean only playing one up top but may avoid us getting overrun?

Not sure why the thread is down voted? Just putting up the video!
[Post edited 14 Dec 16:59]

Never knowingly right.
Poll: How long before new signings become quivering wrecks of the players they were?

1
Login to get fewer ads

Gaffer on today's defeat on 17:09 - Dec 14 with 556 viewsQPRJill

Gaffer on today's defeat on 16:55 - Dec 14 by bosh67

Possibly playing Varane and Hayden as a holding 2 in front of the back 4 in away games would help us cope in midfield in some away games. That does potentially mean only playing one up top but may avoid us getting overrun?

Not sure why the thread is down voted? Just putting up the video!
[Post edited 14 Dec 16:59]


It was just because JS didn`t want to take any blame for the defeat. My downvote was not aimed at you as such..:)
0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 18:03 - Dec 14 with 467 viewsbosh67

Gaffer on today's defeat on 17:09 - Dec 14 by QPRJill

It was just because JS didn`t want to take any blame for the defeat. My downvote was not aimed at you as such..:)


Okay fair enough.

To be fair I think he does shoulder blame for it by not criticising his players. He didn't react quickly enough but I think he knows the set up should have been adjusted much sooner. For me next week is a huge test against Marti. He really does need to try and get that one right selection wise.

Never knowingly right.
Poll: How long before new signings become quivering wrecks of the players they were?

1
Gaffer on today's defeat on 20:41 - Dec 14 with 366 viewsJuzzie

Gaffer on today's defeat on 02:17 - Dec 14 by SydneyRs

I'm referring to those who claim that if only this or that player was picked or this or that formation was used, we wouldn't have lost. After every defeat. The ones that somehow are more qualified than the manager.

We are learning and improving, I think that's obvious. We also have several players and a manager who are new to this division.


if this or that player was picked or this or that formation was used, we wouldn't lose a single game all season. It’s quite easy really.
3
Gaffer on today's defeat on 21:17 - Dec 14 with 334 viewsOldPedro

Gaffer on today's defeat on 20:41 - Dec 14 by Juzzie

if this or that player was picked or this or that formation was used, we wouldn't lose a single game all season. It’s quite easy really.


We still would have lost but maybe we would have put up a better fight

Extra mature cheddar......a simple cheese for a simple man

1
Gaffer on today's defeat on 22:19 - Dec 14 with 290 viewswombat

Gaffer on today's defeat on 18:03 - Dec 14 by bosh67

Okay fair enough.

To be fair I think he does shoulder blame for it by not criticising his players. He didn't react quickly enough but I think he knows the set up should have been adjusted much sooner. For me next week is a huge test against Marti. He really does need to try and get that one right selection wise.


He did t react atall , thats the issue we could see it was horribly wrong everyone could see it was horribly wrong,he changed things as usual round 6o mins in stead of saying at halftime



time to make some so subs . Hate to say it will be the same on sat and likely the same result .

Poll: which is your favouite foot

0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 11:50 - Dec 15 with 189 viewsJuzzie

Gaffer on today's defeat on 21:17 - Dec 14 by OldPedro

We still would have lost but maybe we would have put up a better fight


Mine was just a tongue-in-cheek remark about how post-match analysis often suggests how we could have avoided defeat but if you apply that to every game, then we go the season undefeated!

It's pointing out that it's highly unlikely that will happen so maybe banging on about it each time is a bit fruitless.

Only Preston (in 1888-89) and Arsenal (2003-04) have done that, in the top flight at least. Can't find any data for the other three divisions.
0
Gaffer on today's defeat on 14:18 - Dec 15 with 112 viewsQPRSam

Gaffer on today's defeat on 22:19 - Dec 14 by wombat

He did t react atall , thats the issue we could see it was horribly wrong everyone could see it was horribly wrong,he changed things as usual round 6o mins in stead of saying at halftime



time to make some so subs . Hate to say it will be the same on sat and likely the same result .


I'm not sure how you can say with confidence that JS made 0 adjustments at HT, I thought we looked like a completely different team and I'll back that up with the stark difference in stats comparing 1st and 2nd half below



I think there's an issue here sometimes with posters completely oversimplifying the job of a manager at this level. A change doesn't have to just be a substitution, the same 11 players can be on the pitch but with big adjustments tactically

From pre-season trying to play with a false 9 and building up from the back every time to a 442 direct with two actual 9's, how can you continue to doubt his willingness to adjust?
[Post edited 15 Dec 14:19]
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2025