| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper 10:07 - Aug 12 with 8241 views | SaintNick |
Who is the worst goalkeeper that has played for Saints, criteria is.
1. Keep emotion out of it, Gavin Bazunu is far from the worst keeper that we have had.
2. They have had to have played for the first team more than just a couple of games in an emergency, genuine first team contenders only.
|  |
| Satisfying The Bloodlust Of The Masses In Peacetime |
| |  |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:13 - Aug 12 with 6172 views | dirk_doone |
A few to consider:
Dave MacLaren
Tony Godfrey
Alex McCarthy
Kelvin Davis was once selected for an all-time worst Sunderland XI [Post edited 12 Aug 10:14]
|  |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:19 - Aug 12 with 6115 views | PatfromPoole |
From my time, any one of:
1. Ian Andrews
2. Gavin Bazunu (sorry Nick)
3. Kelvin Davis
Kelvin Davis gets a good press as he didn't leave the Club when we went into administration, and he was at the club when we were promoted twice.
However, he had an appalling shots saved / shots faced ratio (up there with Bazunu), and was bailed out by having such a strong side in front of him. |  |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:21 - Aug 12 with 6106 views | IanSouthstander |
Tommy Forecast. |  | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:23 - Aug 12 with 6091 views | PatfromPoole |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:21 - Aug 12 by IanSouthstander |
Tommy Forecast. |
How many games did he play? | |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:25 - Aug 12 with 6077 views | dirk_doone |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:23 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
How many games did he play? |
Senior career*
Years Team Apps (Gls)
2007–2008 Tottenham Hotspur 0 (0)
2008–2013 Southampton 0 (0)
2009 → Grimsby Town (loan) 4 (0)
2011 → Eastbourne Borough (loan) 5 (0)
2011 → Thurrock (loan) 2 (0)
2011 → Bromley (loan) 11 (0)
2012–2013 → Gillingham (loan) 2 (0)
2013–2014 Chelmsford City 8 (0)
2013 → Dartford (loan) 2 (0)
Total 34 (0) | |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:28 - Aug 12 with 6070 views | SaintNick |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:19 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
From my time, any one of:
1. Ian Andrews
2. Gavin Bazunu (sorry Nick)
3. Kelvin Davis
Kelvin Davis gets a good press as he didn't leave the Club when we went into administration, and he was at the club when we were promoted twice.
However, he had an appalling shots saved / shots faced ratio (up there with Bazunu), and was bailed out by having such a strong side in front of him. |
A few to consider from your time
Neil Moss
Paul Jones (Some good periods and some bad ones)
Paul Smith
Bartoltz Bialkowski
Dave Beasant
Not in your time
Ivan Katalinic
Terry Gennoe
Ian Andrews
I liked some of them as keepers, but they were worse than Gavin Bazunu, as i said keep emotion out of it | |
| Satisfying The Bloodlust Of The Masses In Peacetime |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:29 - Aug 12 with 6064 views | IanSouthstander |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:23 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
How many games did he play? |
Ah. My bad.
He was our number 2 for a while., which was appropriate. | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 11:02 - Aug 12 with 5978 views | PatfromPoole |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:28 - Aug 12 by SaintNick |
A few to consider from your time
Neil Moss
Paul Jones (Some good periods and some bad ones)
Paul Smith
Bartoltz Bialkowski
Dave Beasant
Not in your time
Ivan Katalinic
Terry Gennoe
Ian Andrews
I liked some of them as keepers, but they were worse than Gavin Bazunu, as i said keep emotion out of it |
I did mention Ian Andrews.
Neil Moss is a good shout.
I thought Paul Jones, Bialkowski and Dave Beasant were all largely decent TBF.
Think we would have won the play-off semi-final at Derby if Bialkowski hadn't been dropped and Kelvin Davis put back in for him at the last minute. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 11:10 - Aug 12 with 5962 views | SaintNick |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 11:02 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
I did mention Ian Andrews.
Neil Moss is a good shout.
I thought Paul Jones, Bialkowski and Dave Beasant were all largely decent TBF.
Think we would have won the play-off semi-final at Derby if Bialkowski hadn't been dropped and Kelvin Davis put back in for him at the last minute. |
Bialkowski's confidence was shot to pieces hence he was dropped | |
| Satisfying The Bloodlust Of The Masses In Peacetime |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 12:02 - Aug 12 with 5870 views | hortonsaint |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 11:10 - Aug 12 by SaintNick |
Bialkowski's confidence was shot to pieces hence he was dropped |
Alan Blayney? Chris Woods was well past it too. |  | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 12:25 - Aug 12 with 5834 views | franniesTache |
1. Bazunu
2, Ian Andrews
3. Neil Moss
that's mine, no emotion to it either i genuinely don't think i've seen a worse keep at Saints since i started going in 84 than Bazunu. |  | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:02 - Aug 12 with 5686 views | GreenParkRanger |
Steve Middleton was the worst for me, followed by Ivan the Kat, but only because he couldn't get his goal kicks past the penalty area. | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:33 - Aug 12 with 5636 views | cocklebreath |
Bazanu |  |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:36 - Aug 12 with 5624 views | cocklebreath |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:33 - Aug 12 by cocklebreath |
Bazanu |
Before Bazanu I thought McCarthy was the worst I’d seen but along came your mate to blow him out of the water.
Again no emotion he’s just sh!t | |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:36 - Aug 12 with 5625 views | Tonyfromdk |
Bazunu and Gennoe for me
They were both out their depth playing for us | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:57 - Aug 12 with 5582 views | Butty101 |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 14:36 - Aug 12 by Tonyfromdk |
Bazunu and Gennoe for me
They were both out their depth playing for us |
1 Bazunu
2 Ian Andrews - i remember him letting a couple stinkers in - one where he went to knelt down to collect the ball and it hit a divert and bounced over him.
3 John Burridge still waiting to see him come and claim a cross |  |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 15:49 - Aug 12 with 5525 views | GRIM |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:19 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
From my time, any one of:
1. Ian Andrews
2. Gavin Bazunu (sorry Nick)
3. Kelvin Davis
Kelvin Davis gets a good press as he didn't leave the Club when we went into administration, and he was at the club when we were promoted twice.
However, he had an appalling shots saved / shots faced ratio (up there with Bazunu), and was bailed out by having such a strong side in front of him. |
Having spent an evening with Rickie Lambert last week it was interesting to hear what he said about Kelvn Davis.
Rickie said that KD was brilliant in the dressing room & was so influential to the team spirit
He said that KD helped him & others so much behind the scene.
BUT !, that didn't make him a great goalkeeper, we've had better, notably Anti Niemi who I think was the best. | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 17:15 - Aug 12 with 5431 views | saint22 |
Grobbelaar | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 17:36 - Aug 12 with 5391 views | SalisburySaint |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 10:21 - Aug 12 by IanSouthstander |
Tommy Forecast. |
Got to be the worst but
Steve Middleton
Keith Grainger
Alistair Sperring.
Also not far behind |  | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 19:28 - Aug 12 with 5266 views | saintjeff52 |
Kelvin Davis should not be on this list.
Think back to the days of Nigel Adkins as Manager. Crucial away Game v Leeds, ( Leeds had that megamouth Neil Warnock as Manager in Charge ).
Leeds Pummelled us all Game. Rickie Lambert scored a fabulous Goal, against the run of play.
Kelvin made save after save throughout the Game. He had a wonderful Game, and because of him we WON this crucial Game. The best Goalkeeping performance I've ever seen from our Goalkeeper.
I always remember Warnock' s reaction to the defeat, as Nigel approached him for a handshake after the game.
Clearly heard on live TV from Warnock. "How The £$$& did you win that". Nigel politely said nothing, turned around and walked away. Priceless.
Kelvin dined out for free following that Game. For me, I'll always remember that night, and Kelvin's part in it.
He'll never be included in a List of our worst Goalkeepers |  | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 19:29 - Aug 12 with 5260 views | saintjeff52 |
Kelvin Davis should not be on this list.
Think back to the days of Nigel Adkins as Manager. Crucial away Game v Leeds, ( Leeds had that megamouth Neil Warnock as Manager in Charge ).
Leeds Pummelled us all Game. Rickie Lambert scored a fabulous Goal, against the run of play.
Kelvin made save after save throughout the Game. He had a wonderful Game, and because of him we WON this crucial Game. The best Goalkeeping performance I've ever seen from our Goalkeeper.
I always remember Warnock' s reaction to the defeat, as Nigel approached him for a handshake after the game.
Clearly heard on live TV from Warnock. "How The '££££' did you win that". Nigel politely said nothing, turned around and walked away. Priceless.
Kelvin dined out for free following that Game. For me, I'll always remember that night, and Kelvin's part in it.
He'll never be included in a List of our worst Goalkeepers | | | |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 21:04 - Aug 12 with 5136 views | PatfromPoole |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 19:28 - Aug 12 by saintjeff52 |
Kelvin Davis should not be on this list.
Think back to the days of Nigel Adkins as Manager. Crucial away Game v Leeds, ( Leeds had that megamouth Neil Warnock as Manager in Charge ).
Leeds Pummelled us all Game. Rickie Lambert scored a fabulous Goal, against the run of play.
Kelvin made save after save throughout the Game. He had a wonderful Game, and because of him we WON this crucial Game. The best Goalkeeping performance I've ever seen from our Goalkeeper.
I always remember Warnock' s reaction to the defeat, as Nigel approached him for a handshake after the game.
Clearly heard on live TV from Warnock. "How The £$$& did you win that". Nigel politely said nothing, turned around and walked away. Priceless.
Kelvin dined out for free following that Game. For me, I'll always remember that night, and Kelvin's part in it.
He'll never be included in a List of our worst Goalkeepers |
As they say, a broken watch is right twice a day.
He let in far too many goals which he should have saved. | |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 22:25 - Aug 12 with 5008 views | dirk_doone |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper on 21:04 - Aug 12 by PatfromPoole |
As they say, a broken watch is right twice a day.
He let in far too many goals which he should have saved. |
It's telling that he's remembered for his one good game. If anyone asked what was Kelvin Davis's good game the only reply ever would be Leeds.
With good goalkeepers, there are too many to mention as they are nearly always good. [Post edited 12 Aug 22:27]
| |
| |
| Worst Ever Saints XI Part 1 Goalkeeper (n/t) on 08:40 - Aug 13 with 4763 views | bendybob |
|  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.