| Conundrum for you all. 10:01 - Nov 9 with 1174 views | wombat |
End of the season you can only sign one player on a perm deal
Charles
Kamara
who you going for and why?
[Post edited 9 Nov 11:51]
|  |
| |  |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:11 - Nov 9 with 0 views | daveB |
Charles because he is brilliant although Kamara is a lot more realistic [Post edited 9 Nov 10:11]
|  | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:11 - Nov 9 with 0 views | terryb |
Only one of those will be made available by their parent clubs, so Kamara is an obvious answer.
Charles will be first choice For City (Championship) or second choice (Premier). |  | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:13 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Hoopstar |
Charles as he's brilliant, will only get better and resale profit potential would be huge. Anyone know what City paid for him? Pipiest of pipe dreams however.
Pretty sure we have an option on Kamara as per his deal announcement. Guess the club need to have a good read on his physical conditioning and how quickly his legs will go now he's in his 30s. Is he a Derry or a Johansen? |  | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:43 - Nov 9 with 0 views | aston_hoop |
Charles obviously. If Carl Rushworth went for 25 million quid, the sky is the limit for Charles. Would be a no-brainer, just to make a huge profit on him in a year or 2, which is something we desperately need to be doing. Kamara is great, but it's for Belk and his team to identify and bring in the younger version of him now |  |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:46 - Nov 9 with 0 views | loftboy |
| Conundrum for you all. on 10:13 - Nov 9 by Hoopstar |
Charles as he's brilliant, will only get better and resale profit potential would be huge. Anyone know what City paid for him? Pipiest of pipe dreams however.
Pretty sure we have an option on Kamara as per his deal announcement. Guess the club need to have a good read on his physical conditioning and how quickly his legs will go now he's in his 30s. Is he a Derry or a Johansen? |
£8 Million, we have no chance |  |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:31 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Spaceman_P |
Charles its a no brainer |  | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:45 - Nov 9 with 0 views | TheChef |
Charles - although he's not perfect he makes such a difference to how we play, and surely can only get better.
I mean Kamara is great but he's already 31 years old. |  |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:46 - Nov 9 with 0 views | DavieQPR |
For your answer just look at their ages. [Post edited 9 Nov 11:47]
|  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:51 - Nov 9 with 0 views | wombat |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:46 - Nov 9 by DavieQPR |
For your answer just look at their ages. [Post edited 9 Nov 11:47]
|
taking ages out and possible resale value
whos more important to the team ? | |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:57 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Lblock |
His fee to move back from Chef Weds to Citeh was undisclosed but widely reported as £3Mill rising to £10Mill with add ons.
Sadly we’ve no chance but I’d seriously consider offering Citeh £4Mill or £5Mill this upcoming window just to see….
I think Kamara is mustard and have loved almost every appearance he’s made but the man who has vastly transformed how we’ve played this season is Charles. I was speaking to a wise sage about this post match Saturday and in agreement that it’s mad how a keeper has improved our football through the thirds, although a big caveat that he’s not really had much “rough and tumble EFL pressure” yet.
Kamara would need to be a free and for the right wage.
Charles has that further asset alongside current positive.
Win the play offs and we’ll have em both!!!!! |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 12:11 - Nov 9 with 0 views | daveB |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:57 - Nov 9 by Lblock |
His fee to move back from Chef Weds to Citeh was undisclosed but widely reported as £3Mill rising to £10Mill with add ons.
Sadly we’ve no chance but I’d seriously consider offering Citeh £4Mill or £5Mill this upcoming window just to see….
I think Kamara is mustard and have loved almost every appearance he’s made but the man who has vastly transformed how we’ve played this season is Charles. I was speaking to a wise sage about this post match Saturday and in agreement that it’s mad how a keeper has improved our football through the thirds, although a big caveat that he’s not really had much “rough and tumble EFL pressure” yet.
Kamara would need to be a free and for the right wage.
Charles has that further asset alongside current positive.
Win the play offs and we’ll have em both!!!!! |
yeah even if they have to sell Charles in the summer he will be a level above what we can afford unless we go up. Just enjoy him whilst he's here. | | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 12:51 - Nov 9 with 0 views | TheChef |
When you look at the clowns ManUre and Villa had in goal yesterday, I think we can count ourselves very lucky indeed. | |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 13:01 - Nov 9 with 0 views | LazyFan |
Charles, but it will never happen as hes worth £10m now and everyone knows it.
Even though we have the option after his loan to buy him, I doubt we sign Kamara, as hes on silly money and we can only afford to pay part of it and he has another year on the contract.
I suspect neither will be signed.
Enjoy these nice things before they get taken away for abuse by being at QPR. |  |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 13:11 - Nov 9 with 0 views | QPROslo |
| Conundrum for you all. on 11:51 - Nov 9 by wombat |
taking ages out and possible resale value
whos more important to the team ? |
I was going to say Charles because of his age, but I'd go with him anyway. He's probably more important to the team, though I don't know how good Ward is. Similarly Isak A looked good from what I've seen of him, but that wasn"t much and I wonder why we've not seen more of him. | | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 13:18 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Logman |
Charles, it's a no brainer. But what surprises me is that no other keepers are coming out of the area like him. It literally gives us another player as JD goes to RB and KA goes to to RM.
I'm also concerned that Ward is not playing any games at all and he is not going to be ready to do it if Charles gets injured. We are going to have another Walsh situation on our hands. | | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 14:43 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Myke |
| Conundrum for you all. on 12:11 - Nov 9 by daveB |
yeah even if they have to sell Charles in the summer he will be a level above what we can afford unless we go up. Just enjoy him whilst he's here. |
True to enjoy him now, but I am concerned that Dunne and Edwards are over-reliant on passing back to him already. In fact I don’t even think they consider it a pass ‘back’ at this stage, just part of a passing sequence, and it is only early November. As most know on here, I have more faith in Walsh than most, but whether its him or Ward next season, it is going to be one hell of a culture shock to our defence not to have Charles behind them. In fact I would argue that if Walsh is not getting a game, he should be recalled and both he and Ward spend as much time learning from Charles as possible. Without knowing anything about Ward, I respectfully suggest he will never be as good as Charles, but both he and Walsh need to work on closing the ability gap as much as possible. | | | |
| Conundrum for you all. on 14:55 - Nov 9 with 0 views | kensalriser |
| Conundrum for you all. on 13:01 - Nov 9 by LazyFan |
Charles, but it will never happen as hes worth £10m now and everyone knows it.
Even though we have the option after his loan to buy him, I doubt we sign Kamara, as hes on silly money and we can only afford to pay part of it and he has another year on the contract.
I suspect neither will be signed.
Enjoy these nice things before they get taken away for abuse by being at QPR. |
Kamara will have to weigh up whether he wants to collect the higher wages, finish his contract and then have a problem getting another one because of his age or taking a longer contract on lower initial wages in the summer. Very often a player will take the latter. |  |
| |
| Conundrum for you all. on 15:52 - Nov 9 with 0 views | wombat |
| Conundrum for you all. on 14:43 - Nov 9 by Myke |
True to enjoy him now, but I am concerned that Dunne and Edwards are over-reliant on passing back to him already. In fact I don’t even think they consider it a pass ‘back’ at this stage, just part of a passing sequence, and it is only early November. As most know on here, I have more faith in Walsh than most, but whether its him or Ward next season, it is going to be one hell of a culture shock to our defence not to have Charles behind them. In fact I would argue that if Walsh is not getting a game, he should be recalled and both he and Ward spend as much time learning from Charles as possible. Without knowing anything about Ward, I respectfully suggest he will never be as good as Charles, but both he and Walsh need to work on closing the ability gap as much as possible. |
thing is charles is an oddity in keeping , he would prob look as comftable in a midfield role as he does being in goal , his touch and range of passing put certain midfeld players we have to shame. its the closest you can get to playing professional football with a rush goalie id say.
jjst think he could have been ours on a perm deal last year if only he hadnt of got injured | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.