| Saturday's referee on 09:33 - Sep 16 with 1853 views | E17hoop |
I can't recall seeing a ref ever get higher than an 8 in your ratings. What would a ref have to do to get a 9 or 10? |  |
|  |
| Saturday's referee on 09:40 - Sep 16 with 1832 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 09:33 - Sep 16 by E17hoop |
I can't recall seeing a ref ever get higher than an 8 in your ratings. What would a ref have to do to get a 9 or 10? |
See Mark Clattenburg play off semi final 2nd leg!
For a 9 or 10, i would expect it to be a high pressure match, lots of difficult KMIs (Key Match Incidents), feisty players, feisty benches - all big decisions correct, all cards correct, match under control at all times.
Even in the real world (Marks out of 100) - not many referees get into the 80s at any level.
Its like asking a player to go through a game without missing the target with any shot, misplacing a single pass or misjudging a single tackle - never going to happen. |  | | |
| Saturday's referee on 10:03 - Sep 16 with 1788 views | terryb |
Don't forget how good Clattenberg was in out other play off semi final second leg. And at Hillsborough in 2004.
He has been our best referee/lucky mascot this century! | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 10:25 - Sep 16 with 1735 views | TomS |
| Saturday's referee on 10:03 - Sep 16 by terryb |
Don't forget how good Clattenberg was in out other play off semi final second leg. And at Hillsborough in 2004.
He has been our best referee/lucky mascot this century! |
An honourable mention for Sir Chris Foy. In the 2011-2012 Premiership he gave out 86 yellow cards and 8 reds. Of those, he handed out 7 yellows and 2 reds to one team in one match.
I know, there should have been another red at the end....but it didn't really dilute the euphoria when he blew the final whistle. |  | | |
| Saturday's referee on 10:29 - Sep 16 with 1733 views | Northernr |
| Saturday's referee on 10:03 - Sep 16 by terryb |
Don't forget how good Clattenberg was in out other play off semi final second leg. And at Hillsborough in 2004.
He has been our best referee/lucky mascot this century! |
TBF he was a brilliant referee all round. |  | | |
| Saturday's referee on 17:08 - Sep 16 with 1606 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 10:29 - Sep 16 by Northernr |
TBF he was a brilliant referee all round. |
I agree - bit of a maverick though - outside interests, tatoos - never goes down well, I mean the fact he could actually do the job and do it well..................  | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 17:19 - Sep 16 with 1589 views | Northernr |
| Saturday's referee on 17:08 - Sep 16 by PinnerPaul |
I agree - bit of a maverick though - outside interests, tatoos - never goes down well, I mean the fact he could actually do the job and do it well.................. |
Also not afraid to publicly say which referees he thinks are sht, which I love but I suspect they don't. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Saturday's referee on 17:25 - Sep 16 with 1576 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 17:19 - Sep 16 by Northernr |
Also not afraid to publicly say which referees he thinks are sht, which I love but I suspect they don't. |
Obviously, he got a lucrative offer, but shown a bit more 'love' if you like and considering his age and the possibility of getting the very big games - WC, Euros, CL finals etc at that stage,
he might have stayed longer. | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 18:05 - Sep 16 with 1535 views | terryb |
| Saturday's referee on 17:25 - Sep 16 by PinnerPaul |
Obviously, he got a lucrative offer, but shown a bit more 'love' if you like and considering his age and the possibility of getting the very big games - WC, Euros, CL finals etc at that stage,
he might have stayed longer. |
This might be totally wrong Paul, but didn't he leave after the head of PGMA(?) refused to nominate him as the English referee for a World or European Cup, preferring Mike Dean or some other inferior official?
Again, I might have the wrong administrator, but I think this was all part of Phillip Don's reign. | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 18:14 - Sep 16 with 1524 views | Snipper |
| Saturday's referee on 17:19 - Sep 16 by Northernr |
Also not afraid to publicly say which referees he thinks are sht, which I love but I suspect they don't. |
Who did he name as shìt refs? |  | | |
| Saturday's referee on 18:24 - Sep 16 with 1514 views | paulhoop2 |
Clattenburg excellent. I also liked Dermot Gallaghers way of playing on regardless ! But like qpr fan mark Halsey - actually Halsey reffed us a few times anyone no how that was allowed ??
Worst of all time got to be a tie between Andy Hall and Rob Styles ! Yes I no many would mention Stroud but at times he’s been ok when I’ve seen him and to be fair was let down by his assistant against Sunderland! | |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 18:28 - Sep 16 with 1507 views | Tonto |
| Saturday's referee on 18:24 - Sep 16 by paulhoop2 |
Clattenburg excellent. I also liked Dermot Gallaghers way of playing on regardless ! But like qpr fan mark Halsey - actually Halsey reffed us a few times anyone no how that was allowed ??
Worst of all time got to be a tie between Andy Hall and Rob Styles ! Yes I no many would mention Stroud but at times he’s been ok when I’ve seen him and to be fair was let down by his assistant against Sunderland! |
Worst will always be Gurnam Singh. That has been do e and agreed before. [Post edited 16 Sep 2022 18:30]
|  |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 20:01 - Sep 16 with 1433 views | francisbowles |
Mr Donohue's record with us is 5,3&2. Clive has marked him 7 on all the five wins, 6 on the draw and 4 and 3 on the losses!
He refs well and we win, last four good so lets hope he is good tomorrow. | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 21:15 - Sep 16 with 1393 views | paulhoop2 |
Funny enough tonto said refs son is running the line tomorrow ! | |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 11:41 - Sep 17 with 1277 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 18:24 - Sep 16 by paulhoop2 |
Clattenburg excellent. I also liked Dermot Gallaghers way of playing on regardless ! But like qpr fan mark Halsey - actually Halsey reffed us a few times anyone no how that was allowed ??
Worst of all time got to be a tie between Andy Hall and Rob Styles ! Yes I no many would mention Stroud but at times he’s been ok when I’ve seen him and to be fair was let down by his assistant against Sunderland! |
In his book Halsey basically said he thought he could still referee us fairly, despite being a fan, found out he couldn't, so he owned up! | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 13:51 - Sep 17 with 1190 views | R_from_afar |
Donohue's been decent recently so brace yourself for an absolute 'mare  |  |
| "Things had started becoming increasingly desperate at Loftus Road but QPR have been handed a massive lifeline and the place has absolutely erupted. it's carnage. It's bedlam. It's 1-1." |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 14:11 - Sep 18 with 1127 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 13:51 - Sep 17 by R_from_afar |
Donohue's been decent recently so brace yourself for an absolute 'mare |
Well...usual caveat, will watch the 90' later tomorrow so all live observations from T block!
Thought he had a decent game.
Both sides had two pretty feeble penalty shouts before their big one at the end - still would have benn soft for me.
Missed an obvious shirt pull on Willock early and a foul on Seny, but nothing major wrong IMHO.
The IDFK for Illy must have been because he thought there was no actual contact - no treatment needed, so he may well have been right.
Our old friend added time - 2 mins (1st) and 5 (2nd) for me. Why he played 4 1/2 at the end, having signalled 3 I don't know! | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 14:18 - Sep 18 with 1102 views | EastR |
| Saturday's referee on 14:11 - Sep 18 by PinnerPaul |
Well...usual caveat, will watch the 90' later tomorrow so all live observations from T block!
Thought he had a decent game.
Both sides had two pretty feeble penalty shouts before their big one at the end - still would have benn soft for me.
Missed an obvious shirt pull on Willock early and a foul on Seny, but nothing major wrong IMHO.
The IDFK for Illy must have been because he thought there was no actual contact - no treatment needed, so he may well have been right.
Our old friend added time - 2 mins (1st) and 5 (2nd) for me. Why he played 4 1/2 at the end, having signalled 3 I don't know! |
Not sure about the rest but when 3 mins added time started he then booked their keeper for time wasting over the free kick by the touchline, so that will account for some of it. | |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 14:41 - Sep 18 with 1070 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 14:18 - Sep 18 by EastR |
Not sure about the rest but when 3 mins added time started he then booked their keeper for time wasting over the free kick by the touchline, so that will account for some of it. |
Yes, right in front of me, but never took 1 1/2 minutes! | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 15:00 - Sep 18 with 1052 views | EastR |
| Saturday's referee on 14:41 - Sep 18 by PinnerPaul |
Yes, right in front of me, but never took 1 1/2 minutes! |
We're living in inflationary times  | |
| |
| Saturday's referee on 15:17 - Sep 18 with 1036 views | Northernr |
I had him down for a 7/8 going into the last minute. He then adds three minutes to a half with subs, injury, a time wasting yellow, and a minute of applause for the queen, and at the end of that waves off one of the more blatant penalties you'll see. Perhaps he knew the last Avanti to Manchester is much earlier now and wanted to get off. | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 16:22 - Sep 18 with 951 views | PinnerPaul |
| Saturday's referee on 15:17 - Sep 18 by Northernr |
I had him down for a 7/8 going into the last minute. He then adds three minutes to a half with subs, injury, a time wasting yellow, and a minute of applause for the queen, and at the end of that waves off one of the more blatant penalties you'll see. Perhaps he knew the last Avanti to Manchester is much earlier now and wanted to get off. |
Interested to see the pen shout for myself tomorrow - as ever in football opinions differ - I've seen blatant dive and blatant penalty on here now! | | | |
| Saturday's referee on 17:02 - Sep 18 with 928 views | Noelmc |
At the match I thought it was a definite penalty, but looked a lot softer on the ITV highlights as Stoke player went down very easily.
Probably one of those that refs will give outside the box but not inside. Silly challenge for Paal to make at that stage though. |  | | |
| Saturday's referee on 17:21 - Sep 18 with 897 views | Northernr |
| Saturday's referee on 16:22 - Sep 18 by PinnerPaul |
Interested to see the pen shout for myself tomorrow - as ever in football opinions differ - I've seen blatant dive and blatant penalty on here now! |
If we hadn't been given that I'd have literally exploded into a thousand pieces. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
