| Is the Championship a bit rubbish 13:31 - Nov 18 with 3516 views | Myke | Two of the divisions stand out performers - Azaz and Manning were very very average for us in the last two games. Azaz brief flashes of brilliance but mostly anonymous. Manning one peach of a cross for Parott but often struggling against the oppo winger. Smyth not getting game time for NI. Makes me wonder what is the standard of the Championship on a global scale.? |  | | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 13:49 - Nov 18 | turnsey | Regarding Smyth and Northern Ireland, the people keeping him out of a team that have been performing well against decent international sides are mostly Championship players themselves. Their starting lineup against Hungary was 2 Prem players, 7 Championship, and 2 League 1. Goes to show you can probably make an argument both ways. [Post edited 18 Nov 13:52]
|  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 14:20 - Nov 18 | PlanetHonneywood | @ Myke - I think the clue is that despite being the fourth biggest league in football, it is still the second tier of the English game. I don't know if there is a second tier in Ireland or Norn Iron for that matter, but I'd wager that there are more players from the English second tier gracing the international scene, than the second tiers of any other country. |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 16:35 - Nov 18 | Logman | I think it's probably quite hard for a Championship player to translate his skills to a national team. They don't get to train with them much, the style of play might be completely different and the oppositions can be a lot stronger than a Championship team. I think the standard in the Championship is by and large pretty good. I enjoy watching it anyway. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 16:44 - Nov 18 | Wilkinswatercarrier | I think it says more about the standard of youth football and coaching in Ireland, N Ireland, Scotland and Wales that very very few players from those countries now play in the PL let alone being top international players. Go back 30/40 years and the top division was awash with great players from the UK & Ireland. Not anymore. |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 17:43 - Nov 18 | bosh67 | I prefer the Championship to the Prem. We've been in the Championship long enough. At least any team can beat any team on any given day in this league. |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 18:50 - Nov 18 | CiderwithRsie | I'll have you know that getting into the 1st team of a Championship side is enough to attract interest from A C Milan in QPR youngster Leon Scarlett. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:06 - Nov 18 | TK1 | Two things: 1/ As Wilkins points out, it's the second tier. Are they expected to be European national team quality, one of the best 11 or so players from their country? 2/ Despite that, a Google reveals that more Championship players were called up by their nations this break than players from La Liga and Bundesliga. So relatively speaking, if that's not made-up bollox - could be - that makes the Championship a pretty good level. Here are the numbers: Premier League – 220 Serie A – 150 Ligue 1 – 112 CHAMPIONSHIP – 107 🔥 Bundesliga – 106 La Liga – 100 https://www.instagram.com/p/Df Not sure how many internationals Ligue 2 or Bundesliga 2 delivered, but I'd rather watch the Championship football. How was Vale when he came on for Manning? |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:16 - Nov 18 | switchingcode | Having experienced the premier league for the last 5 seasons the championship the previous 6 and div 1 and div 2 for the best part of 50 years.I would say the championship is the best by a country mile. |  | |  | Login to get fewer ads
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:28 - Nov 18 | Boston |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:16 - Nov 18 by switchingcode | Having experienced the premier league for the last 5 seasons the championship the previous 6 and div 1 and div 2 for the best part of 50 years.I would say the championship is the best by a country mile. |
Wish they wouldn't call it the Championship though, it's very confusing. |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:42 - Nov 18 | colinallcars | I'm happy as a sandbag in the Championship. No refs with stars in their eyes, no VAR, more 3pm kickoffs and you're aways in with a shout no matter who you're up against. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 21:50 - Nov 18 | Konk | Absolutely my favourite division as someone who supports a team who aren't going to win the PL. Plenty of good away days, generally local support, good away followings, football can be good, relatively affordable, no VAR, and often unpredictable. |  |
| Fulham FC: It's the taking part that counts |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 22:36 - Nov 18 | Myke |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:06 - Nov 18 by TK1 | Two things: 1/ As Wilkins points out, it's the second tier. Are they expected to be European national team quality, one of the best 11 or so players from their country? 2/ Despite that, a Google reveals that more Championship players were called up by their nations this break than players from La Liga and Bundesliga. So relatively speaking, if that's not made-up bollox - could be - that makes the Championship a pretty good level. Here are the numbers: Premier League – 220 Serie A – 150 Ligue 1 – 112 CHAMPIONSHIP – 107 🔥 Bundesliga – 106 La Liga – 100 https://www.instagram.com/p/Df Not sure how many internationals Ligue 2 or Bundesliga 2 delivered, but I'd rather watch the Championship football. How was Vale when he came on for Manning? |
Vale was a bit like he is for QPR. Got off to a flying start, put in a sublime ball straight away which led to a corner and this then led to the 2nd Pen . Took a couple of decent corners but then his influence faded as the half went on, even though Ireland were quite dominant at that stage. Much better than against Austria though. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 07:21 - Nov 19 | gazza1 | The Championship is an OK league, competitive between the teams in the league. Most players are not good enough for a 'proper' premiership league which is the best in the world by a long way. If we got promoted with the team/players that we have then relegation is a certainty - most, if not all. would need to be replaced if we had any ambition of PL football. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 19:22 - Nov 19 | numptydumpty | Regards the "Championship", Substitute it for the "Box of Chocolates" In a famous Forrest Gump quote. "Life is like ...... You never know what you going to get." [Post edited 19 Nov 19:23]
|  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 20:01 - Nov 19 | NewBee |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 13:49 - Nov 18 by turnsey | Regarding Smyth and Northern Ireland, the people keeping him out of a team that have been performing well against decent international sides are mostly Championship players themselves. Their starting lineup against Hungary was 2 Prem players, 7 Championship, and 2 League 1. Goes to show you can probably make an argument both ways. [Post edited 18 Nov 13:52]
|
For Smyth/NI it's purely tactical. Since they have no strikers worth the name, O'Neill concentrates on defence first, with 3 x CB's and 2 x WB's. His preferred WB's are both Championship players, Devlin/Pompey and Devenny/Stoke, whose primary role is to defend, as auxillary FB's. Then depending on how the game is going, they get ordered to push up i.e. more "Wing" than "Back". Meaning it is not entirely coincidental that they each scored a cracker in the second half, from the edge of the box, in their last two games. (Devenny's vs Hungary is esp worth searching YouTube for). I know that Smyth is a hard worker, but maybe O'Neill doesn't feel he's quite so suited to the role as the others, esp the enormous physicality required? While the other thing working against him is that he's now 29, which shouldn't seem old, but it would have made him the oldest NI starter the other evening, in a team with an average age of 23! (Devlin turned 23 earlier this month, with Devenny 23 in October.) That said, the fact that O'Neill keeps including Smyth in his squads, and he keeps turning up, shows that there is mutual respect etc. But O'Neill is clearly building for the future, and it's paying off. [Post edited 19 Nov 20:04]
|  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 20:19 - Nov 19 | NewBee |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 16:44 - Nov 18 by Wilkinswatercarrier | I think it says more about the standard of youth football and coaching in Ireland, N Ireland, Scotland and Wales that very very few players from those countries now play in the PL let alone being top international players. Go back 30/40 years and the top division was awash with great players from the UK & Ireland. Not anymore. |
It may partly be explained by the standard of coaching and development in SCO/WAL/NIR/ROI not keeping up with the best of other countries. But that's only half the story (imo). Which is that 30 or 40 years ago, there were hardly any imports from outside the British Isles. Whereas now, not only are PL clubs importing loads of players from all over the world, but they've the money to cherry pick the very best of them. Meaning that most of those players from the rest of the British Isles who were good enough to play in the English top flight back then would not get a look-in at top flight clubs these days. (Also, there were 22 x 1st Division clubs back then, but only 20 x PL clubs these days, which has further reduced opportunities). So I actually suspect the standard of those players is probably greater than back then, but thanks to the standard and numbers of the foreign imports, the difficulty of finding a place in a top-flight PL club is greater again. I actually think the Championship is a very respectable standard. And if you were to reduce it from 24 clubs to the 20/18/16 x clubs you see in most foreign leagues, both top and second flight, then it would compare even better. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 20:23 - Nov 19 | joolsyp |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 20:01 - Nov 19 by NewBee | For Smyth/NI it's purely tactical. Since they have no strikers worth the name, O'Neill concentrates on defence first, with 3 x CB's and 2 x WB's. His preferred WB's are both Championship players, Devlin/Pompey and Devenny/Stoke, whose primary role is to defend, as auxillary FB's. Then depending on how the game is going, they get ordered to push up i.e. more "Wing" than "Back". Meaning it is not entirely coincidental that they each scored a cracker in the second half, from the edge of the box, in their last two games. (Devenny's vs Hungary is esp worth searching YouTube for). I know that Smyth is a hard worker, but maybe O'Neill doesn't feel he's quite so suited to the role as the others, esp the enormous physicality required? While the other thing working against him is that he's now 29, which shouldn't seem old, but it would have made him the oldest NI starter the other evening, in a team with an average age of 23! (Devlin turned 23 earlier this month, with Devenny 23 in October.) That said, the fact that O'Neill keeps including Smyth in his squads, and he keeps turning up, shows that there is mutual respect etc. But O'Neill is clearly building for the future, and it's paying off. [Post edited 19 Nov 20:04]
|
Devlin is developing a habit of scoring crackers from outside the box! Good player, like him a lot. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 22:48 - Nov 19 | Northernr | Yes. |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 07:45 - Nov 20 | Wilkinswatercarrier |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 20:19 - Nov 19 by NewBee | It may partly be explained by the standard of coaching and development in SCO/WAL/NIR/ROI not keeping up with the best of other countries. But that's only half the story (imo). Which is that 30 or 40 years ago, there were hardly any imports from outside the British Isles. Whereas now, not only are PL clubs importing loads of players from all over the world, but they've the money to cherry pick the very best of them. Meaning that most of those players from the rest of the British Isles who were good enough to play in the English top flight back then would not get a look-in at top flight clubs these days. (Also, there were 22 x 1st Division clubs back then, but only 20 x PL clubs these days, which has further reduced opportunities). So I actually suspect the standard of those players is probably greater than back then, but thanks to the standard and numbers of the foreign imports, the difficulty of finding a place in a top-flight PL club is greater again. I actually think the Championship is a very respectable standard. And if you were to reduce it from 24 clubs to the 20/18/16 x clubs you see in most foreign leagues, both top and second flight, then it would compare even better. |
I'd agree up to a point on the foreign players now in the PL, but that doesn't excuse the drop off in standard in say Scottish domestic football. It is awful. But no way can we say top Scottish players today are a better standard to the great players of the 80s - Hansen, Dalglish, Souness, Nicol, McClair, Strachan it goes on. Still rubbish in World Cups mind. It is poor youth setups and poor incompetent leadership. |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 11:06 - Nov 20 | Spaceman_P |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 07:45 - Nov 20 by Wilkinswatercarrier | I'd agree up to a point on the foreign players now in the PL, but that doesn't excuse the drop off in standard in say Scottish domestic football. It is awful. But no way can we say top Scottish players today are a better standard to the great players of the 80s - Hansen, Dalglish, Souness, Nicol, McClair, Strachan it goes on. Still rubbish in World Cups mind. It is poor youth setups and poor incompetent leadership. |
Internationally i think no one cares about the championship. But I think within the UK, I feel even fans of higher teams feel the championship is what football used to be. I mean the premier league is a totally different animal as it was in the 90s. I hope that the championship still has a rawness to it... even if the quality is questionable |  | |  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 12:38 - Nov 20 | Antti_Heinola | I think the question of quality is of course relative. I do roll my eyes a bit at the sort of slightly condescending stuff about the standard of the Championship. It's clearly a very high standard but no, obviously, not as high as the Premier League. The PL may be the best league in the world, whether that's by a long way or not is debatable (the Conference League winners list certainly suggests it has greater depth for sure), but it has its fair share of absolutely dreadful and boring games: last season was an atrocious season, of awful football based on long throws and set pieces, for example. But I echo a lot of sentiments here: I love the championship, I love there's no VAR, and I think you still see a very decent quality of football. But I don't only watch for 'quality' - how boring is that? |  |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 13:58 - Nov 20 | Konk |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 11:06 - Nov 20 by Spaceman_P | Internationally i think no one cares about the championship. But I think within the UK, I feel even fans of higher teams feel the championship is what football used to be. I mean the premier league is a totally different animal as it was in the 90s. I hope that the championship still has a rawness to it... even if the quality is questionable |
You say that, but on holiday last year, my son was wearing a Bristol City cap which just has the robin on it without any wording, and a waiter in Lyon and a bar owner in Paris, both went, "Ah, Bristol City from the Championship!" when they saw it, which has convinced my son that they have some massive following throughout France! If you compare the stadiums, crowds, some of the players, histories etc of a lot of the clubs, I think it is probably up there with all but a handful of major leagues in Europe. The football can be a bit dire at times, but there's plenty of rank games in the PL too. Plenty of derbies this season too. For me, going to a PL game and being surrounded by tourists or fans who've chosen to follow a trophy-winning club, who also happen to be the 34th closest side to where they have grown-up, just feels a bit crap. |  |
| Fulham FC: It's the taking part that counts |
|  |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 14:14 - Nov 20 | Konk |
| Is the Championship a bit rubbish on 22:48 - Nov 19 by Northernr | Yes. |
To be fair, if I went to Blackburn, Stoke, Preston, Boro, and Watford away every year for as long as you have, I might have a different view of the division! Mates have started booking up holidays in the sun for the February half-term, and I've got an overnighter in Blackburn to look forward to as my son has never been to Ewood. Midweek in Blackburn in February watching two teams I don't support. Good times. [Post edited 20 Nov 14:14]
|  |
| Fulham FC: It's the taking part that counts |
|  |
| |