| Paul Smyth back out on loan 12:47 - Sep 22 with 4682 views | bosh67 |
In various papers about him going out on loan again. Seems a bit mad really considering he's looked sharp and at it in his sub performances so far. Plus we are risking a horrible lack of options if Manning or/and BOS go. Hope it's paper talk? |  |
| |  |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 12:50 - Sep 22 with 3218 views | Northernr |
Playing for the U23s v Ipswich this afternoon. Strong team we've put out. |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 12:52 - Sep 22 with 3199 views | daveB |
Barmy he's gone from young player of the year to not being picked for 2 years. We need to give him a chance this season |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 12:55 - Sep 22 with 3168 views | LythamR |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 12:52 - Sep 22 by daveB |
Barmy he's gone from young player of the year to not being picked for 2 years. We need to give him a chance this season |
yes, he has looked sharp and put in decent balls, I want to seen him play, he also ads a bit of friction and fire on the field, i certainly wouldnt send him on load until sure whats happening with BOS and any potential incoming replacement |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:00 - Sep 22 with 3135 views | slmrstid |
If he goes out on loan again I'd guess thats him finished at QPR. A shame as when he burst onto the scene he looked like he had something about him, but those who have seen him in training over the last 2 years know more I guess.
Hopefully he stays and makes a good fist of being a QPR player though. |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:12 - Sep 22 with 3077 views | T_Block |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:00 - Sep 22 by slmrstid |
If he goes out on loan again I'd guess thats him finished at QPR. A shame as when he burst onto the scene he looked like he had something about him, but those who have seen him in training over the last 2 years know more I guess.
Hopefully he stays and makes a good fist of being a QPR player though. |
Agree that it is strange to send him out on loan as I think most fans rate him.
In fact i would like to see him start a few games..
Maybe the striker coming in needs to start but I get the feeling he is not been given a fair chance.
It appears obvious the opposition have big problems dealing with him I do not understand.why he wasn't picked at Wycombe and why he does not get more chance now |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:19 - Sep 22 with 3033 views | LazyFan |
Seems to be ahead of Shodipo.
If, we are brining in another winger like Jordon Jones, then before loaning out Smyth we should loan out Shodipo. I think for loans we can pick and choose em, as clubs seem to be asking us for players down the leagues from what Warbs said.
Smyth should stay in the squad unless BOS signs with another winger. Which I doubt will happen. So, Smyth should stay then, he's ready. |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:19 - Sep 22 with 3034 views | Gloucs_R |
rather than sending him out on loan again, with his contract ending next summer, then why wouldn't we just give him away for free and include a sell on percentage . |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:45 - Sep 22 with 2935 views | aston_hoop |
Apparently he has an assist and won a penalty so far, Oteh scoring both goals (and missing the penalty)
For me I do find it strange how managers have been quite quick to jduge him on very little game time, for me given how he looked in pre-season he'd be well worth a run |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:47 - Sep 22 with 2927 views | Gloucs_R |
rather than sending him out on loan again, with his contract ending next summer, then why wouldn't we just give him away for free and include a sell on percentage . | |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 14:34 - Sep 22 with 2791 views | QPROslo |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 13:12 - Sep 22 by T_Block |
Agree that it is strange to send him out on loan as I think most fans rate him.
In fact i would like to see him start a few games..
Maybe the striker coming in needs to start but I get the feeling he is not been given a fair chance.
It appears obvious the opposition have big problems dealing with him I do not understand.why he wasn't picked at Wycombe and why he does not get more chance now |
Think he was out a lot with injuries during his loan at Wycombe.
My memories of Smyth are that he seemed to disappear from games when given more time on the park, lively in a short substitute appearance but less so the longer he played. Hopefully he has improved now. | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 17:26 - Sep 22 with 2528 views | Antti_Heinola |
5-0 in the U23 game.
A sign of how we shouldn't react too much to scores at that level (win or lose). |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 18:19 - Sep 22 with 2365 views | NewBee |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 12:52 - Sep 22 by daveB |
Barmy he's gone from young player of the year to not being picked for 2 years. We need to give him a chance this season |
Might it simply be that Smyth (signed in Jul 2017, breakthrough in Jan 2018) just isn't what Warburton (arrived May 2019) rates/wants, with injuries compounding the situation? | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 18:27 - Sep 22 with 2361 views | DavieQPR |
The only thing I saw was that a few Div 1 sides have asked to be notified if he comes up for sale. |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 18:32 - Sep 22 with 2349 views | Gloucs_R |
Nor championship clubs..... League 1 clubs..... | |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 19:20 - Sep 22 with 2237 views | daveB |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 18:19 - Sep 22 by NewBee |
Might it simply be that Smyth (signed in Jul 2017, breakthrough in Jan 2018) just isn't what Warburton (arrived May 2019) rates/wants, with injuries compounding the situation? |
I don't doubt that Warburton doesn't rate him I just don't know what that's based on when he's never picked him and find it all a bit disapointing | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 19:55 - Sep 22 with 2130 views | bosh67 |
A friend of mine who works at Leeds and is also from Ireland says they are keeping tabs on him to bring him on if it doesn't work out here. If Leeds and the Northern Irish national team set up still think he still has something to offer then it seems a bit foolish for us to not be pushing the peddle down hard to bring him along. He has blistering pace and he can finish. I'd like to see him finally come through with us. He's only 23. | |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 19:58 - Sep 22 with 2121 views | onlyrinmoray |
The squad is pretty thin we can hardly afford to lose players of his quality Like others I can’t figure why Warbuton doesn’t give him a start |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 21:40 - Sep 22 with 1966 views | traininvain |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 19:20 - Sep 22 by daveB |
I don't doubt that Warburton doesn't rate him I just don't know what that's based on when he's never picked him and find it all a bit disapointing |
How many managers haven’t picked him and / or decided to send him out on loan?
It must be at least two or three. Maybe it’s to do with his size or could be something else but Warburton isn’t the first to decide he’s surplus to requirements. |  | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 21:46 - Sep 22 with 1946 views | Myke |
Think he scored on his debut for Wycombe last season and then picked up a nasty injury. With Wycombe motoring and playing a very direct style he found it hard to get back in. I like him, good work rate and brings a bit of an 'edge'. Think he would be competing with Thomas for a spot though. | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 21:50 - Sep 22 with 1930 views | BrianMcCarthy |
I have to say I've never been too sure about him. Love his attitude and he has some speed but not sure he's ready for this division. Shame he had so many injuries while at Wycombe. |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 22:41 - Sep 22 with 1821 views | daveB |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 21:40 - Sep 22 by traininvain |
How many managers haven’t picked him and / or decided to send him out on loan?
It must be at least two or three. Maybe it’s to do with his size or could be something else but Warburton isn’t the first to decide he’s surplus to requirements. |
2 managers, McClaren and now Warburton | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 22:59 - Sep 22 with 1765 views | Myke |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 21:40 - Sep 22 by traininvain |
How many managers haven’t picked him and / or decided to send him out on loan?
It must be at least two or three. Maybe it’s to do with his size or could be something else but Warburton isn’t the first to decide he’s surplus to requirements. |
Being sold is indicative of being 'surplus to requirements', going out on loan not so. Or at least not anymore, nowadays it seems to be an accepted part of their development. Football has changed considerably; once upon a time being released on a 'free' was the ultimate insult for a player -Bosman has changed all that. | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 23:03 - Sep 22 with 1758 views | southbrookstreet |
whats best for him... the bread-man knows the situation more than us | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 09:47 - Sep 23 with 1527 views | daveB |
whatever you think of him good or bad I do think we'd be mad to loan out a player with first team experience when we have so many games this season in short bursts. That goes for the likes of Gubbins and bettache as well. May well be better for their development to play but club need to make sure they have enough bodies to cover injuries, illness etc | | | |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 09:53 - Sep 23 with 1489 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Paul Smyth back out on loan on 09:47 - Sep 23 by daveB |
whatever you think of him good or bad I do think we'd be mad to loan out a player with first team experience when we have so many games this season in short bursts. That goes for the likes of Gubbins and bettache as well. May well be better for their development to play but club need to make sure they have enough bodies to cover injuries, illness etc |
Agreed. We look very thin. | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
