| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis 12:32 - Nov 14 with 2456 views | Northernr | Can't remember which of you requested for the next international break, but we put Zac on this for you and here's the data and analytics on Pierce Charles... https://www.fansnetwork.co.uk/ |  | | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 13:08 - Nov 14 with 0 views | KensalT | Great piece Zac. I have one question. You say Charles is 'par for the course' for shot stopping. Is that par for all goalkeepers or just Championship keepers? Reason I ask is that if the data says he's an average Championship shot stopper that might count against him in the Premier League where the strikers are a lot more efficient at finishing their chances. Basically I'm looking for a 'weakness' in his game that might give us a chance of hanging on to him. He would be a worthy wearer of the hallowed Number 10 shirt. Although you'd probably have to prise it out of Chair's dead fingers to get it off him. [Post edited 14 Nov 21:33]
|  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 14:07 - Nov 14 with 0 views | Dorse | Great work all round Zak - I particularly liked the animations you included to illustrate the tactical / positional changes. I know we're not supposed to fall in love with loan players but I think Pierce is going to be tough to get over. |  |
| 'What do we want? We don't know! When do we want it? Now!' |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 14:14 - Nov 14 with 0 views | TwoHalves | I was certainly one who requested it although I’m sure there must been others, so first thing’s first, let me say how much I appreciate it. I was struck by Pierce as soon as I saw him in some of the pre-season friendlies when it became obvious that we had something special on our hands. I like to think that I can see exactly what’s going on from my perch in the Upper Loft, but to actually put it into words like Zac is something else entirely. The piece could easily be a university degree dissertation, IMHO. As a slightly daft aside, this message board has taught me a lot over the years, not least how long to boil an egg for to achieve the perfect consistency between ‘runny’ and ‘hard’ (six minutes, since you ask). Thinking six minutes would allow me to sit down and read the article this morning, I started the egg-boiling process. Needless to say I became so engrossed in the piece that I completely forgot about my breakfast, resulting in two rock hard eggs and a burned out saucepan. Anyway, enough of this drivel. Just to say thanks once again, Clive, for commissioning the piece and to young Zac for so brilliantly bringing it to life. PS: The Pierce Charles ‘Pass Map’ is a thing of beauty. Can it be made available as a giant poster please?! |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 14:17 - Nov 14 with 0 views | CLAREMAN1995 |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 13:08 - Nov 14 by KensalT | Great piece Zac. I have one question. You say Charles is 'par for the course' for shot stopping. Is that par for all goalkeepers or just Championship keepers? Reason I ask is that if the data says he's an average Championship shot stopper that might count against him in the Premier League where the strikers are a lot more efficient at finishing their chances. Basically I'm looking for a 'weakness' in his game that might give us a chance of hanging on to him. He would be a worthy wearer of the hallowed Number 10 shirt. Although you'd probably have to prise it out of Chair's dead fingers to get it off him. [Post edited 14 Nov 21:33]
|
Without getting hackles raised I think he has that weakness but his overall game covers for it and more . Keepers at this level and above are required to make the stunning save ,spring up and save the rebound then even a 3rd effoet if the defenders are not back slaying for him. Charles has let in 3 or 4 pretty soft ones this year IMO but still on a different level that our previous keepers. Speaking of City their so called world class keeper Donnarumma is turning into a very average one for City and Italy massive errors this season that wont be tolerated for long . Charles wont be recalled of course probably a top ranked loan in Jan |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 15:36 - Nov 14 with 0 views | Beckenhamhoop | I did speculate earlier this season as to whether Callum Ward and Salomon had changed their training to, in effect, mimic Charles’ exact style of play should he move on in January or get injured. I think this is almost certain to be the case. I wonder what Ward and Salomen’s thoughts on this would be and whether they consider themselves better keepers as a result. An interview with either of the backups to Charles or the head of goalkeeper training would be interesting to listen to the impact of having an almost revolutionary goalkeeper in our midst. [Post edited 14 Nov 15:38]
|  |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 16:45 - Nov 14 with 0 views | EuroRanger | Brilliant analysis, very well put together. Thank you Zac! |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 17:00 - Nov 14 with 0 views | LoftInsights |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 13:08 - Nov 14 by KensalT | Great piece Zac. I have one question. You say Charles is 'par for the course' for shot stopping. Is that par for all goalkeepers or just Championship keepers? Reason I ask is that if the data says he's an average Championship shot stopper that might count against him in the Premier League where the strikers are a lot more efficient at finishing their chances. Basically I'm looking for a 'weakness' in his game that might give us a chance of hanging on to him. He would be a worthy wearer of the hallowed Number 10 shirt. Although you'd probably have to prise it out of Chair's dead fingers to get it off him. [Post edited 14 Nov 21:33]
|
Hi, appreciate it! The percentile comparisons are in relation to Championship goalkeepers. However, goals prevented is calculated as xGOT (a post-shot xG measure; essentially the probability that a shot-on-target results in a goal) - goals conceded. In this sense, the 'par-for-the-course' comment is referring to how the model predicts he'd perform (actual vs. expected). Difficult to know exactly how this would translate to the Premier League, as he can only save the shots that he faces, of course. Meeting expectations in this way won't make headlines like a massive overperformance might, however it's not a bad thing by any means (particularly compared to Walsh, who underperformed greatly last season). I think by virtue of his on-the-ball ability alone, he will play in the Premier League. Unfortunately unless Man City end up in non-league and we go up, I can't see it being with us. [Post edited 15 Nov 21:43]
|  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 17:36 - Nov 14 with 0 views | dmm | Thanks very much, Zac. A great piece that does Charles justice. I appreciated your mention of Ward and that he has at least some of Charles' qualities. Assuming he'll be taking the no 1 shirt next season, as fans we'll need to be extra encouraging toward him as it'll be a huge vacancy to fill. |  | |  | Login to get fewer ads
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 17:38 - Nov 14 with 0 views | superhoopaus | Great analysis Zac. We should try and buy him in January |  |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 18:29 - Nov 14 with 0 views | QPunkR |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 17:38 - Nov 14 by superhoopaus | Great analysis Zac. We should try and buy him in January |
As well as Haaland, Zidane, Messi and Maradona |  |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 20:05 - Nov 14 with 0 views | Rsole | It and he is brilliant, especially in terms of distribution, passing and confidence at the back. Only QPR could build a strategy around a loan keeper though. Another four year plan with a one year break clause in the making. Hope he stays, plan for the worst. |  |
| Those possessed by devils, try and keep them under control a bit, can't you ?
|
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 22:22 - Nov 14 with 0 views | Myke |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 20:05 - Nov 14 by Rsole | It and he is brilliant, especially in terms of distribution, passing and confidence at the back. Only QPR could build a strategy around a loan keeper though. Another four year plan with a one year break clause in the making. Hope he stays, plan for the worst. |
Thanks Zak, your analyses confirms the eye test. However, signing Charles on loan is only a viable move if we get promoted. He is designed to give us a short term ‘competitive advantage’ and that is all. If we don’t get promoted then for a team in our financial position, it is a year wasted of Ward’s development. I was never a believer in treating loan players differently than permanent signings -once they pull on the QPR shirt they are ours. Signing a GK on loan however, is different than signing an outfield player, as he is clearly impeding the progress of a specific player. However, there is no doubt from the data that Charles has contributed significantly to us being in the play-offs, if that leads to promotion, then clearly a very successful strategy. Interesting six months ahead. |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 08:57 - Nov 15 with 0 views | londonscottish | Charles kept his 5th consecutive clean sheet for NI and pulled off an instinctive worldy. Martin O'Neill said "You don't keep 446 minutes of clean sheets just because you're good on the ball". |  |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 11:38 - Nov 15 with 0 views | enfieldargh | Great piece sums up our beautiful boy in a nutshell City do have another ball playing two footed keeper Jack Wint who is on loan at Kidderminster Harriers According to radio presenter James O’brian he’s never seen a keeper who passes the ball saves penalties and is 2 footed Look harder James |  |
|  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 12:31 - Nov 15 with 0 views | QPROslo |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 22:22 - Nov 14 by Myke | Thanks Zak, your analyses confirms the eye test. However, signing Charles on loan is only a viable move if we get promoted. He is designed to give us a short term ‘competitive advantage’ and that is all. If we don’t get promoted then for a team in our financial position, it is a year wasted of Ward’s development. I was never a believer in treating loan players differently than permanent signings -once they pull on the QPR shirt they are ours. Signing a GK on loan however, is different than signing an outfield player, as he is clearly impeding the progress of a specific player. However, there is no doubt from the data that Charles has contributed significantly to us being in the play-offs, if that leads to promotion, then clearly a very successful strategy. Interesting six months ahead. |
I'm not sure the loan signing of Charles "is a year wasted of Ward's development." If as it seems from reports of the way Ward is playing in Development team games are correct, he is learning much of what Pierce is doing from the man himself. The GK's train together as a Group so some of Pierce's game should be picked up by the other Keepers to our benefit. |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 19:51 - Nov 15 with 0 views | FDC | Thanks for this, really excellent. The section on how PC stepping into the back like supports overloads higher up the pitch was really useful. "Charles’ 45.3% long ball accuracy places him in the 94th percentile among Championship goalkeepers" I'm actually surprised he's not the 100th percentile on this measure! Who has better long ball accuracy? |  | |  |
| How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis on 20:03 - Nov 15 with 0 views | BrianMcCarthy | Really enjoyed this. Very easy to understand and well illustrated. Thanks Zac. |  |
|  |
| |