Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team 13:27 - Sep 7 with 9977 viewsnumptydumpty

For me the Most Overrated Band is undoubtedly ;

OASIS



Most Overrated Solo artist ;

TOM JONES



Most Overrated Football club is ;

LIVERPOOL (especially their wonderful fans)
Closely followed by the not so mighty SPURS




Will have to have a think on Under Rated counterparts !!!
[Post edited 7 Sep 13:31]

"Walking in a Mackie Wonderland"
Poll: Main Reason you started following QPR ??

0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 11:17 - Sep 8 with 2362 viewsizlingtonhoop

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 09:55 - Sep 8 by Bluce_Ree

I always thought Radiohead were shit and I maintain that all their popular albums were. But when they fked that all off and did Kid A they changed.

Musically they are unbelievably good. I'm not sure I actually like much of it but there is shit they do that is on a different level.

Not a band ii love but one I can respect.


I've felt the same for simply red for about 30 years. Their music is brilliantly done. But I don't care for it.

He did a good job with the Faces, by many am account.
-1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 13:23 - Sep 8 with 2177 viewsSpaceman_P

Radiohead are a band i like and hate in equal measures.... they really are one of those groups.

I think maybe Thom Yorke's pretentiousness is what makes me dislike them... plus i find hus vocal styling annoying.

As for UB40 agree with the guys above... huge fall from grace, mind blowing in fact.... thats a whole topic in itself bands who were good thdn total cack later.
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 13:50 - Sep 8 with 2135 viewsLogman

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 13:23 - Sep 8 by Spaceman_P

Radiohead are a band i like and hate in equal measures.... they really are one of those groups.

I think maybe Thom Yorke's pretentiousness is what makes me dislike them... plus i find hus vocal styling annoying.

As for UB40 agree with the guys above... huge fall from grace, mind blowing in fact.... thats a whole topic in itself bands who were good thdn total cack later.


Black Uhuru - great mix of stonking dub and bass, earthy vocals and jingly beats in the 80's - synthetic, poppy, dross in the 2000's

But quite a few reggae bands seem to go that way - Bob was the same and Aswad also, to a degree. They get tamed.
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 14:29 - Sep 8 with 2074 viewsnick_hammersmith

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 11:17 - Sep 8 by izlingtonhoop

I've felt the same for simply red for about 30 years. Their music is brilliantly done. But I don't care for it.

He did a good job with the Faces, by many am account.


Thanks for this!!



I never knew this went down, even a cheeky Pistol in the band ;p
Actually pretty good rendition, capturing the chaos of a drunken Faces gig I reckon
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 14:50 - Sep 8 with 2034 viewsjoe90

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 09:55 - Sep 8 by Bluce_Ree

I always thought Radiohead were shit and I maintain that all their popular albums were. But when they fked that all off and did Kid A they changed.

Musically they are unbelievably good. I'm not sure I actually like much of it but there is shit they do that is on a different level.

Not a band ii love but one I can respect.


Brave choice!

I know I'll get crucified for this, but I'll say it anyway...I can't stand the Beatles. I think they're so naff. Always think of this from Bowie:

0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 15:11 - Sep 8 with 2004 viewsnick_hammersmith

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 14:50 - Sep 8 by joe90

Brave choice!

I know I'll get crucified for this, but I'll say it anyway...I can't stand the Beatles. I think they're so naff. Always think of this from Bowie:



Bowie just went even further up in my opinion.

There has always been a difference between important and popular.

Popular is how we end up with David Gray, Dido and Nigel Farage.

Important can be things that are not or will ever be popular.
But how do we rate something? On popularity or talent?
1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 15:18 - Sep 8 with 1989 viewskensalriser

You're not alone, I can't stand The Beatles either. Although to be more accurate, it's really everything up to Rubber Soul plus all the novelty stuff. They were the first band I got into as a pre-teen, so I'm very familiar with all the albums and quite a lot of the solo stuff. Then I discovered Kraftwerk and punk happened and I never went back. So now I regard The Beatles as kids' music.

Poll: QPR to finish 7th or Brentford to drop out of the top 6?

1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 15:36 - Sep 8 with 1950 viewsizlingtonhoop

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 14:50 - Sep 8 by joe90

Brave choice!

I know I'll get crucified for this, but I'll say it anyway...I can't stand the Beatles. I think they're so naff. Always think of this from Bowie:



You are Robert Elms and I claim my five pounds
3
Login to get fewer ads

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 16:46 - Sep 8 with 1860 viewsnick_hammersmith

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 15:18 - Sep 8 by kensalriser

You're not alone, I can't stand The Beatles either. Although to be more accurate, it's really everything up to Rubber Soul plus all the novelty stuff. They were the first band I got into as a pre-teen, so I'm very familiar with all the albums and quite a lot of the solo stuff. Then I discovered Kraftwerk and punk happened and I never went back. So now I regard The Beatles as kids' music.


They were literally the One Direction or Take That of the 60's
Kids music
-4
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 17:29 - Sep 8 with 1816 viewsNed_Kennedys

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 16:46 - Sep 8 by nick_hammersmith

They were literally the One Direction or Take That of the 60's
Kids music


I understand not everyone likes or appreciates the Beatles but that’s just nonsense and I say that as someone who doesn’t even care for them that much.
10
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 17:34 - Sep 8 with 1803 viewshubble

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 16:46 - Sep 8 by nick_hammersmith

They were literally the One Direction or Take That of the 60's
Kids music


Christ what utter b*ll*cks! Which is what my beloved Dave Bowie is talking in that vid. And you lot above as well.

Anyway, there are thousands of candidates for most overrated and several have been covered here, but to put the Beatles in that category is just plain ignorant. Sure, I get it, you don't like some of McCartney's more saccharin ditties or their early outings, but he did also pen Paperback Writer, Blackbird and Eleanor Rigby.....I could go on, but I know I'm wasting my time.

Most underrated: I often think it's Joni Mitchell.... certainly when compared to her peers like Dylan....



PS - I reckon you were on a fishing trip Nick, and I took the bait!
[Post edited 8 Sep 17:37]

Poll: Who is your player of the season?

4
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 18:13 - Sep 8 with 1735 viewsBluce_Ree

Clive. Is there a super-moderator that I can contact?

I know you deal with the regular on-going business of the forum but I need someone with the authority to ban people and then put them in prison. I also want to be compensated so the moderator will need to sell the banned users' assets and give all the money to me.

With that in mind, I ask a simple question (pun sort of intended). Why the f**k is Mick f**king Cocknall being talked about somewhat positively on my favourite football forum?!

Mick isn't over-rated or under-rated. He's c*nter-rated. F**king Mick f**king C*nt Huckc*nt. What a c*nt.

C*NT!

Biggest c*nt since Kerry Katona's vag.

EDIT: "Post contains unacceptable language" - missed a c*nt!

Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore.

5
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 19:09 - Sep 8 with 1672 viewsrbee

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 16:46 - Sep 8 by nick_hammersmith

They were literally the One Direction or Take That of the 60's
Kids music


Someone with a straight face once told me that Mozart was the Robbie Williams of classical music.

I like The Beatles but I have to admit that they were over hyped sometimes. There was a time that you knew nothing about popular music unless Sgt Pepper was your favourite album. As the years passed so many people admitted that they actually preferred Rubber Soul or Revolver.

The Beatles influence over popular music will never be surpassed, see Oasis, and like it or not they will be talked about forever not only for their records but songwriting and recording techniques. There was actually a rule book published by EMI that everyone had to adhere to when recording music for release on EMI labels. Beatles engineer Geoff Emerick was the first to go against the rule book and he very nearly lost his job.

I rarely listen these days.
[Post edited 8 Sep 19:24]
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 19:19 - Sep 8 with 1648 viewsBluce_Ree

Also.

BB King/Eric Clapton. 60+ year careers playing the same fking blues scale. How do you play that long and not just shift your finger up or down a fret just to see how it sounds?

Foo Fighters. How do you go from being in Scream and Nirvana to playing dad rock? It's just so safe.

Pink Floyd. F**k me. I don't know anyone who doesn't like them but I've never heard a song by them that isn't intensely dull. I'm sure they're good musicians but f**king hell, unlistenable to me.

Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore.

1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 19:41 - Sep 8 with 1620 viewskensalriser

I was going to add Foo Fighters earlier. Tired, shouty, tuneless, interminably dull drivel. Wouldn't have lasted a year had it not been for the Nirvana connection.

Poll: QPR to finish 7th or Brentford to drop out of the top 6?

0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 20:31 - Sep 8 with 1557 viewscolinallcars

I'm surprised at all the Elton John critiscism.
Some of his songs like All Quiet On The Western Front and Don't Let The Sun Go Down are lovely. He uses a simple but effective technique called pedal point which adds plangency to some songs.
I have a video of him where his band is augmented with choir and orchestra. It really is good.
As for him “not being able to play piano”, that's just not so.
I actually saw him when he was Reg Dwight playing in Alexis Korner's band.
1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 20:46 - Sep 8 with 1528 viewsSpaceman_P

Foo fighters my god each song sounds the exact same.

In the words of Peter Cook.... Dave Ghrol is so chummy
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 22:08 - Sep 8 with 1438 viewswillesdenr

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 14:43 - Sep 7 by PlanetHonneywood

Most Overrated Band: UB40 - Anyone who starts out with 'One in 10' and 'Earth Die Screaming', and allows themselves to degenerate to stuff like, 'There's a Rat in the Kitchen' and 'Red, Red Wine' are, in my humble, c..ts.

Most Overrated Solo Artist: Taylor Swift - And not only that love, you ain't a looker either!

Most Overrated Football Team: Spurs!


Oi, one of my favourite songs is Food for Thought but with you on the simpering Taylor Swift.

Most over rated band Coldplay
Most overrated singer Engelbert Humperdinck
Most overrated team the scum down the road
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 22:17 - Sep 8 with 1417 viewsQPRJill

Overrated bands: Rolling Stones, Nirvana, The Kinks.
Underrated bands: Prefab Sprout, Alan Parson`s Project, Rainbow and Barclay James Harvest.
Overrated solo artists: Joe Cocker and Michael Jackson.
Underrated solo artist: Gerry Rafferty and Al Stewart.

Overrated football team: Leeds United.
Underrated football team: QPR.
[Post edited 11 Sep 21:32]
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 07:58 - Sep 9 with 1229 viewsjoe90

Another one for Foo Fighters. They’re sh*t. Agree with all comments.
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 09:40 - Sep 9 with 1168 viewsizlingtonhoop

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 07:58 - Sep 9 by joe90

Another one for Foo Fighters. They’re sh*t. Agree with all comments.


I've sometimes imagined, out loud, in the pub,
Dave goes into the studio
"Right everyone, here's my latest..."
Picks up guitar.
Yanga, yanga, yang yang yang
"Yeh Dave, we get it"
Muttering ensues

I will admit, driving back from Manchester United, Ashley Young dive and all, I was playing a Jam collection, with my now sadly late best friend (into dance and prog) alongside.

"Oops," I said "I put on the wrong track there"
Dry as a bone, he said "How can you tell..?"
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 12:42 - Sep 9 with 1068 viewscharmr

I think the Beatles song writing (folk chords) has hugely influenced modern music.

3 chords velvet underground stuff a good starter for new guitar players and a band learning to play together. When the riffs stop and the song writing appears the real test unfolds.

Bunnymen a good example

James on a bit of a revival of late but a hugely underrated band for years.
Overrated, Kings of Leon/The Killers
[Post edited 9 Sep 12:46]
1
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 12:49 - Sep 9 with 1054 viewsLogman

Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 12:42 - Sep 9 by charmr

I think the Beatles song writing (folk chords) has hugely influenced modern music.

3 chords velvet underground stuff a good starter for new guitar players and a band learning to play together. When the riffs stop and the song writing appears the real test unfolds.

Bunnymen a good example

James on a bit of a revival of late but a hugely underrated band for years.
Overrated, Kings of Leon/The Killers
[Post edited 9 Sep 12:46]


'3 chords velvet underground stuff a good starter for new guitar players and a band learning to play together. When the riffs stop and the song writing appears the real test unfolds'

It never stopped Quo ...
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 18:46 - Sep 9 with 936 viewscharmr

Quo you mean matchstick men(great song or the louder meaner grungier Chuck Berry Quo.

You’re in the army now. Painful
0
Most OVER/UNDER RATED Band/Solo Artist /Football Team on 08:00 - Sep 10 with 801 viewswestberksr

overrated band = any of and all of the reality TV manufactured shite; but of those classed as 'real' bands then Coldplay, the middle class home counties dinner party band of choice. Every song seems to have Mr Martin going woowooowooowwoohooo through a chorus where other songwriters put actual words

overrated solo artist - Michael Jackson, was all about the writers, producers & videos. Off The Wall was a great album, but lets face it, he's not a patch on Prince for overall talent

underrated artist - countless acts that never get the credit i felt they deserved when a sea of untalented shite seems to prevail in modern music, particularly in the charts

overrated team - The Scum - bought success with dirty Oligarch money & special mention to World Cup winners Wet Spam; basking in the glory of 4 players from the mid 60s for 60 years now.

underrated team - Palace & Brighton (they'll love being thrown together) for punching above weight consistently, but more so Brighton for extracting hundreds of millions off the scum over the years

As for The Beatles, never a fan but considering their relatively short career together compared to others, the output and impact on music is incredible........ still don't nor ever will own any though
1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026