| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:09 - Apr 18 with 4770 views | Tonto |
Given how much rolling Kelman does whereas the Fleetwood player lays still, I would say Kelman is play acti g and the Fleetwood player is genuinely injured.
Not smart from either player though. |  |
|  |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:25 - Apr 18 with 4625 views | swisscottage |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:09 - Apr 18 by Tonto |
Given how much rolling Kelman does whereas the Fleetwood player lays still, I would say Kelman is play acti g and the Fleetwood player is genuinely injured.
Not smart from either player though. |
I don't think you can necessarily draw the conclusion that Kelman was play acting.
When I got run over in my 20s and broke tib and fib, I was rolling around on the ground and then tried to get up only for my leg to give way underneath me :). being hurt doesn't necessarily mean you lie still afterwards. |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:46 - Apr 18 with 4495 views | E17hoop |
|  |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:50 - Apr 18 with 4471 views | bosh67 |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:46 - Apr 18 by E17hoop |
|
In the days I grew up and played football that was called a tackle. |  |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:57 - Apr 18 with 4423 views | Logman |
I think a three match ban for serious foul play is getting off light for that. Reckless is an under-statement | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:07 - Apr 18 with 4376 views | danehoop |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:57 - Apr 18 by Logman |
I think a three match ban for serious foul play is getting off light for that. Reckless is an under-statement |
which one? |  |
| Never knowingly understood |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:15 - Apr 18 with 4324 views | Logman |
I think Kelman's is worse. Though as someone just said, thirty years ago that was no more than a free-kick .... | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:20 - Apr 18 with 4301 views | swisscottage |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:15 - Apr 18 by Logman |
I think Kelman's is worse. Though as someone just said, thirty years ago that was no more than a free-kick .... |
or in Hoddle's case not even that. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:30 - Apr 18 with 4235 views | Hunterhoop |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:15 - Apr 18 by Logman |
I think Kelman's is worse. Though as someone just said, thirty years ago that was no more than a free-kick .... |
Freeze it at 5 seconds. The Fleetwood player’s tackle is far worse. They both go in with two feet but the Fleetwood player doesn’t go for the ball he goes above/to the right of the ball and two foots Kelman in the chest. Kelman goes in in line with the ball, both legs bent at the knee (so somewhat of a knee slide) and catches the Fleetwood bloke in the arse by the looks of it. Maybe it was the back of his leg and rode up, but it was at the ball; the Fleetwood lad does not look to be going for the ball to me, he’s looking to use his body to stop/block it, allowing him to follow through and catch Kelman.
Of course, that assessment could be wrong. But 0.05 looks bad. |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:34 - Apr 18 with 4224 views | Northernr |
Referee's right. Both red cards. Good for him being brave enough to give it. |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:38 - Apr 18 with 4194 views | Logman |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:30 - Apr 18 by Hunterhoop |
Freeze it at 5 seconds. The Fleetwood player’s tackle is far worse. They both go in with two feet but the Fleetwood player doesn’t go for the ball he goes above/to the right of the ball and two foots Kelman in the chest. Kelman goes in in line with the ball, both legs bent at the knee (so somewhat of a knee slide) and catches the Fleetwood bloke in the arse by the looks of it. Maybe it was the back of his leg and rode up, but it was at the ball; the Fleetwood lad does not look to be going for the ball to me, he’s looking to use his body to stop/block it, allowing him to follow through and catch Kelman.
Of course, that assessment could be wrong. But 0.05 looks bad. |
Yes, I see what you mean. The benefit of slow motion replays/VAR. Kelman was a red card waiting to happen though. sliding in like that. Reminds me of Leigertwood. | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:56 - Apr 18 with 4112 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:15 - Apr 18 by Logman |
I think Kelman's is worse. Though as someone just said, thirty years ago that was no more than a free-kick .... |
and thank goodness that has changed! |  |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 22:28 - Apr 18 with 3989 views | sevenhoop |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:56 - Apr 18 by Antti_Heinola |
and thank goodness that has changed! |
May have been some Kelman frustration as apparently he had missed a sitter just before it |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 11:43 - Apr 19 with 3533 views | Tonto |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 20:25 - Apr 18 by swisscottage |
I don't think you can necessarily draw the conclusion that Kelman was play acting.
When I got run over in my 20s and broke tib and fib, I was rolling around on the ground and then tried to get up only for my leg to give way underneath me :). being hurt doesn't necessarily mean you lie still afterwards. |
the third roll over followed by the head over heels looks very suspect to me. the momentum from the challenge is over, and the extra rolls are unnecessary unless you are going for 9.5 from the French judge in my opinion. | |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 13:06 - Apr 19 with 3384 views | davman |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:34 - Apr 18 by Northernr |
Referee's right. Both red cards. Good for him being brave enough to give it. |
Maybe, but apparently he gave the Gills a free kick for that. How can he do that then send them both off? So, the Fleetwood one was a foul, but Kelman's one not?
All a bit strange. |  |
| |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 17:06 - Apr 19 with 3144 views | PinnerPaul |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:34 - Apr 18 by Northernr |
Referee's right. Both red cards. Good for him being brave enough to give it. |
Yes I agree, but with both injured its difficult not to.
Just had to pick one for the free kick guess, technically its whoever committed the first foul, but with no VAR impossible to pick, so no one is going to argue, especially given where the incident was. | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 02:25 - Apr 20 with 2902 views | Match82 |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 17:06 - Apr 19 by PinnerPaul |
Yes I agree, but with both injured its difficult not to.
Just had to pick one for the free kick guess, technically its whoever committed the first foul, but with no VAR impossible to pick, so no one is going to argue, especially given where the incident was. |
Waiting to hear what ref chat had to say about this one Pinner! |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 03:10 - Apr 20 with 2892 views | ozexile |
They're both lucky they can still walk. That's 2 career ending tackles. | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 07:38 - Apr 20 with 2732 views | stevec |
2 goals in 23 games, I’m reading. |  | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 18:04 - Apr 20 with 2499 views | PinnerPaul |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 02:25 - Apr 20 by Match82 |
Waiting to hear what ref chat had to say about this one Pinner! |
Not had time to go on there, or here much - stop the clapping at the back - if I get a chance will ask/see on there! | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 19:59 - Apr 20 with 2348 views | distortR |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 17:06 - Apr 19 by PinnerPaul |
Yes I agree, but with both injured its difficult not to.
Just had to pick one for the free kick guess, technically its whoever committed the first foul, but with no VAR impossible to pick, so no one is going to argue, especially given where the incident was. |
Ideally it would be a contested drop ball with the two who went into each other competing.
Ding Ding! round two | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 17:11 - Apr 21 with 2061 views | PinnerPaul |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 19:59 - Apr 20 by distortR |
Ideally it would be a contested drop ball with the two who went into each other competing.
Ding Ding! round two |
I know you're only joking but that's wrong on many levels, not least the fact that contested drop balls no longer exist!  | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:14 - Apr 21 with 1971 views | distortR |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 17:11 - Apr 21 by PinnerPaul |
I know you're only joking but that's wrong on many levels, not least the fact that contested drop balls no longer exist! |
I know, and I know one of the two couldn't walk, but it would have been exciting. Uncontested drop balls, yawn. | | | |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 18:27 - Apr 22 with 1687 views | PinnerPaul |
| Charlie Kelman Red Carded in Double Sending off on 21:14 - Apr 21 by distortR |
I know, and I know one of the two couldn't walk, but it would have been exciting. Uncontested drop balls, yawn. |
They may well be boring but footballers still don't understand how they work! | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
