| Chopping, changing, tactics 20:32 - Aug 25 with 3726 views | rich_dale |
Not a regular poster on here and never started a post but am doing so today to address the biggest issue at the moment on the pitch. I wasn’t there today but had reports from those who were, and I did watch the Peterborough game, plus follow all the others so feel qualified enough to vent my opinion. I’m not for a minute a ‘Hill out’ fan and he has brought more good times to my time supporting Dale (30 years) than any other manager, but there has been a developing problem over the last 2/3 seasons which is now becoming a massive one.
For me, what Hill is good at historically is recruitment (bar the odd failure), developing young players, fixing broken toys and all that, and I agree with his statement the other day that our squad is better this season than last. But it’s becoming clear he doesn’t know how to use the players he’s got. From game to game, and during games, the personnel, formation and tactics change so much, as a fan you just wonder whether he knows what he’s doing. And bringing in a new RB and keeper so soon into the season without any apparent need for cover is troubling.
It seems like he’s constantly searching for a combination that works, either in setting up the team before the games or during them, and the players get switched around so much it can’t be good for them. I could list some examples but we'd be here all day. We’ve got away with it for the last two years, but every Saturday before kick off, as fans we’ve usually no idea what the team will be or how they’ll line up — it’s fine if we win but we obviously struggled last season and have just lost our first three home games. Yes we played Peterborough and Barnsley in the first two, bigger budgets etc but we made it much easier than it should have been. Today we lost at home to an average team by all accounts.
We need a proper, settled strategy that suits the players and makes them comfortable, and less switching when the game is going on. I don’t care about stats that show how many miles everyone runs, I want to see us more decisive at both ends of the pitch and that comes from having an effective, stable system where everyone knows their jobs, a way of playing that everyone is happy with and much less chopping and changing. We could run 20 miles more than the opposition during a game without affecting the result. And playing out from the back and knocking it around prettily like Man City looks nice but this is League One and has created more problems than benefits.
Hill can’t keep blaming each loss on player ‘mistakes’ as happened yet again today. Some proper questions from journalists about tactics after games would help to enlighten fans as I’m not sure what the plan is to win games or what’s going on in Keith’s head. But would that be blasphemy?
|  | | |  |
| Chopping, changing, tactics on 22:05 - Aug 25 with 3596 views | 442Dale |
Really good post.
Many would wish he’s questioned around tactics more so we could understand his thought processes. However, that doesn’t happen at present and would require someone who knows what they’re talking about to do it. |  |
| |
| Chopping, changing, tactics on 22:26 - Aug 25 with 3551 views | kiwidale |
An excellent well articulated post I couldn't agree more it is Hills fault. | |
| This is not the time for bickering.
|
| |
| Chopping, changing, tactics on 22:26 - Aug 25 with 3548 views | Aucklandjeff |
I think Hilly has made the mistake of pinning all his preparation on the success of the 3-5-2. His vision is admirable (possession based) but we don't have the calibre of player to be effective in that system at this level. He consistently bemoans individual mistakes which show players are not comfortable with playing it. I wonder if the players believe in it? If not does the playing group have the freedom to voice there concerns to Hilly and offer alternatives? For me, the system needs two outstanding wing backs which we do not have (hence the signing of Randell...very highly thought of from a Liverpool supporter I know) and we are desperately lacking pace out wide.
I think Hilly has been too ambitious with this vision of possession-based football. Back to 4-3-3 in possession and 4-5-1 without ball, bring fullbacks into play when possible to support attack. break with pace and don't play around in our last 3rd...sorted! :) | | | |
| Chopping, changing, tactics on 23:59 - Aug 25 with 3451 views | _DailyDale |
This is exactly what I saw today | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
